Finance and Economics Discussion Series: Accessible versions of figures for 2026-046

Sequence-Space Jacobians of Life-Cycle Models

Accessible version of figures


Figure 1: Age Structure and Life-Cycle Profiles in Steady State
Notes: the top left panel depicts the share of households of each age in the initial steady state of the model. The other panels depict the part of aggregate labor supply (\(N_t\)), net taxes \(T_t\), and total savings \(A_t\) that is due to each age group in steady state.

This four-panel figure shows how the steady-state population and aggregate economic outcomes are distributed across ages from approximately 26 to 100. Each panel contains one solid black line.

Top-left panel, Age Distribution. The horizontal axis is age and the vertical axis is the share of all households at each age, expressed as a percentage. The share is slightly above 2 percent for the youngest households and declines slowly through middle age. It then declines more rapidly after about age 70, falling below 1 percent near age 80 and approaching zero by age 100. The downward slope reflects population growth and mortality: younger cohorts are larger and more of their members remain alive.

Top-right panel, Total Labor Supply. The horizontal axis is age and the vertical axis is the age group's contribution to aggregate effective productivity. The contribution starts near 1 for the youngest workers, rises to a peak of roughly 2.6 around age 50, and declines modestly through the early 60s. It drops sharply to zero at retirement, around age 65, and remains zero thereafter.

Bottom-left panel, Total Taxes Minus Transfers. The horizontal axis is age and the vertical axis is the age group's contribution to aggregate net taxes. Net taxes are positive during working life, rising from about 0.2 for young workers to approximately 0.6 around age 50, then declining slightly before retirement. At retirement, the line drops abruptly to approximately negative 1.5 because retirees receive net transfers. The negative contribution gradually moves back toward zero as mortality reduces the size of older age groups.

Bottom-right panel, Total Wealth. The horizontal axis is age and the vertical axis is the age group's contribution to aggregate savings. Wealth is near zero for the youngest households, rises throughout working life, and peaks slightly above 10 around age 65. It then declines as retirees draw down their assets or die, and approaches zero by age 100.

Return to text.


Figure 2: Examples of Life-Cycle Jacobians
Notes: The left panel shows the response to a one-time, anticipated increase in the real return of savings that occurs in year 10. The right panel shows the response to a one-time increase in the growth rate of newborn cohorts that occurs in year 10. In both panels, the total response is decomposed into the contributions of working-age households and retirees.

This two-panel figure decomposes aggregate responses into the contributions of working-age households and retirees. In both panels, time from 0 to 100 is on the horizontal axis. The solid black line is the total response, the dashed blue line is the contribution of workers, and the dashed orange line is the contribution of retirees.

Left panel, Savings Per Capita Response to a 1 Percentage Point Interest Factor Shock. The vertical axis is the response of savings per capita, expressed as a percent of steady-state savings. The anticipated, one-time increase in the return on savings occurs in year 10. Before year 10, workers slightly increase savings while retirees slightly reduce savings. At the time of the shock, the total response jumps to just under 1 percent; workers and retirees each contribute roughly one-half percentage point. The workers' contribution returns to zero by about year 35, while the retirees' contribution declines more slowly and keeps the total response positive until roughly year 55.

Right panel, Labor Per Capita Response to a 10 Percentage Point Newborn Cohort Growth Shock. The vertical axis is the response of labor per capita, expressed as a percent of steady-state labor. The one-time increase in newborn cohort growth occurs in year 10. The total response initially falls, reaching approximately negative 0.5 percent around year 18, because the additional young workers have relatively low productivity. It then rises to about positive 2.3 percent around year 50 as the larger cohorts become more productive. After year 50, the workers' contribution remains near positive 2.3 percent, while the retirees' contribution falls toward negative 2.3 percent as the larger cohorts retire. These contributions offset one another, so the change in total labor per capita returns to approximately zero by year 80.

Return to text.


Figure 3: The Birth Rate Shock and its Mechanical Effects on Population

This two-panel figure shows the demographic effects of permanently reducing newborn cohort growth from 0.30 percent per year to zero in year 0.

Panel A, Population Growth Rates. The horizontal axis runs from 25 years before the shock to 100 years after it, and the vertical axis is annual growth in percent. The solid blue line for newborn growth is 0.30 percent before the shock and drops vertically to zero in year 0. The dashed orange line for total population growth also begins at 0.30 percent but declines gradually rather than immediately. It is about 0.15 percent after 25 years, about 0.03 percent after 50 years, and approaches zero after roughly 75 years, when the demographic transition is complete.

Panel B, Age Structure Along the Transition. The horizontal axis contains three displayed age bins: ages 20-45, ages 46-65, and ages 65 and older. The vertical axis is each group's percentage-point change from its initial population share. Three bars per group show years 18, 37, and 75. The youngest group's share falls by approximately 0.7, 1.6, and 1.9 percentage points at those dates. The middle group's share rises by approximately 0.4 percentage point in year 18, peaks near 0.6 in year 37, and ends around 0.3. The oldest group's share rises steadily by approximately 0.3, 1.0, and 1.5 percentage points.

Return to text.


Figure 4: Equilibrium Responses to a Permanent Decline in the Birth Rate

This six-panel figure shows the general-equilibrium transition after the permanent decline in newborn cohort growth. In every panel, the horizontal axis runs from 25 years before the shock to 100 years after it. The solid line is the transition path. A black dotted horizontal line marks the initial steady state and a red dotted horizontal line marks the terminal steady state.

Panel A, Output per Capita. Output begins near 2.877, rises after the shock, and peaks near 2.893 in year 27. It then falls, crosses below its initial level around year 47, and converges to a terminal level near 2.867.

Panel B, Labor per Capita. Labor begins near 1.899 and rises slightly to a peak near 1.902 in year 18 as the working-age population temporarily shifts toward more productive ages. It then falls substantially and converges to a terminal level near 1.876 by roughly year 65.

Panel C, Capital per Capita. Capital begins near 7.503, rises strongly, and peaks near 7.638 in year 37. It then declines gradually but remains above its initial level, converging to approximately 7.583.

Panel D, Tax Rate. The tax rate begins near 0.232 and rises monotonically toward approximately 0.2445.

Panel E, Wage. The wage begins at 1.000, rises after the shock, and peaks near 1.010 around year 49. It then declines slightly to a terminal value near 1.009.

Panel F, Interest Rate. The gross interest rate begins near 1.0200 and declines to a trough near 1.0175 around year 50. It then recovers slightly and converges to a terminal value near 1.0178, which remains below the initial rate.

Return to text.


Figure 5: Dynamic Decomposition of Asset Demand and Supply

This two-panel figure decomposes the transition path of capital into the effects of individual forces. The horizontal axis is years after the shock, from 0 to 100. Both panels share a vertical scale of approximately 7.3 to 7.85. The solid black line is the total equilibrium path, which rises from about 7.50 to a peak near 7.64 around year 37 and then converges near 7.58. Each other line shows the path that would result from one factor acting alone, with all paths starting from the same initial level.

Panel A, Asset Demand or Savings. The dashed red age-structure line is the largest positive force, rising steadily toward approximately 7.85 because older households save more. The solid orange wage-rate line is also positive, rising gradually toward approximately 7.59. The dotted green tax-rate line is negative, falling toward roughly 7.34 because higher taxes reduce households' resources. The dash-dotted blue interest-rate line is the largest negative force, falling to approximately 7.31 around year 65 and ending near 7.32. The combination of these differently timed forces produces the hump-shaped total path.

Panel B, Asset Supply or Capital. The dash-dotted blue interest-rate line rises to approximately 7.71 around year 48 and remains near 7.70, showing that the lower equilibrium interest rate encourages firms to demand more capital. The dashed red age-structure line, which combines changes in labor and population growth, falls to approximately 7.39, showing that the eventual decline in labor per capita reduces firms' desired capital. These opposing forces combine to produce the same total equilibrium capital path shown in the left panel.

Return to text.


Figure C.1: Household Model Fit of Life-Cycle Income and Wealth

This two-panel appendix figure compares age profiles in Survey of Consumer Finances data with their model-implied counterparts. The horizontal axis in both panels contains five-year age bins from ages 26-30 through ages 91-95. Colored solid lines with markers show the data's 25th, 50th, and 75^(th) percentiles. Black dashed lines with markers show the corresponding model-implied percentiles.

Left panel, Income. The vertical axis is income in thousands of dollars. At every age, the 25th, 50th, and 75th percentiles are ordered from lowest to highest. All three data series rise through early and middle working life and then decline. The data's 75th percentile rises from about $94,000 at ages 26-30 to a peak near $165,000 at ages 46-50, then declines to about $58,000 at ages 91-95. Median income peaks near $87,000, and the 25th percentile peaks near $50,000. The dashed model lines reproduce the broad hump shapes and the spread across percentiles, although they are smoother and differ from the data in some age bins.

Right panel, Wealth-to-Income Ratio. The vertical axis is wealth divided by income. The ratio generally rises with age, and the dispersion across percentiles becomes much larger for older households. In the data, the 25^(th) percentile remains close to zero, the median rises from about 0.2 to roughly 1.1-1.7, and the 75th percentile rises from about 0.6 to approximately 11 for ages 91-95, with some fluctuations at older ages. The model reproduces the strong age gradient and widening dispersion. Its 75th percentile rises smoothly to about 9 at ages 91-95, while its 25th percentile is essentially zero throughout.

Return to text.


Figure D.1: Non-Zero Elements of Age-Specific Fake News Matrices $\Fn_{t,s}(j)$
Notes: each panel depicts the zero and non-zero elements of \(\mathcal{F}(j)\) for different values of \(j\). Non-zero elements are black and zero elements are white. The depicted matrices correspond to the response of consumption (\(C\)) to the interest factor \(R\).

This appendix figure contains three black-and-white matrix panels for households aged 30, 55, and 80. In every panel, the horizontal axis is the time when an interest-rate shock occurs, denoted by *s*, from 0 to 100. The vertical axis is the time of the consumption response, denoted by *t*, from 0 at the top to 100 at the bottom. Black cells are nonzero elements of the age-specific fake-news matrix; white cells are zero. A cell can be nonzero only when the household is alive both when the shock is announced and when it occurs.

Left panel, Age 30. The nonzero region is a very thin black strip along the top of the matrix. Responses are possible only during approximately the first four response years, and shocks occurring as late as roughly year 70 can matter because a 30-year-old has a long remaining lifespan.

Middle panel, Age 55. The nonzero region is a larger triangular or trapezoidal area in the upper-left portion of the matrix.

Right panel, Age 80. The nonzero region extends down through approximately the first 54 response years but is narrower with respect to distant shock dates.

The three panels demonstrate the sparse structure used by the algorithm: most combinations of household age, response time, and shock time are known to have zero effect and do not need to be computed.

Return to text.


Figure D.2: Age- and Cohort-Specific Jacobians of Consumption
a) Consumption Response to \(1\) p.p. increase in \(R\), by age groups
b) Consumption Response to \(1\) p.p. increase in \(R\), by cohorts
Notes: \(t\) denotes the time since the shock was announced and \(s\) denotes the time when the shock occurs. Responses are normalized by steady-state aggregate consumption of the relevant age group or cohort at the given time. Panel a) shows the dynamic responses of different age groups; a given household can move across groups as time advances. Panel b) shows the dynamic responses of different cohorts of households; cohorts are indexed by their age at time \(0\). These responses are cut short when the cohorts exit the model, as they reach age 100.

This appendix figure has two labeled parts, each containing three panels for ages 30, 55, and 80. Every panel shows the relative consumption response to a 1 percentage point increase in the interest factor. The horizontal axis is time since the shock was announced, from 0 to 60, and the vertical axis is the response relative to the relevant group's steady-state consumption. Three lines represent shocks that occur immediately, after 20 years, or after 40 years, denoted by *s* equals 0, 20, and 40. The horizontal dashed line marks zero response.

Part A, Age-specific responses. These panels describe the response of households who are a specified age at each date; the membership of each age group changes over time. For age 30, anticipated shocks in years 20 and 40 produce small negative consumption responses before the shock, reaching approximately negative 0.1 percent, followed by an abrupt return to zero when the shock occurs. The immediate-shock response is approximately zero. For age 55, an immediate shock produces a positive response near 0.18 percent that declines to zero. Shocks in years 20 and 40 generate negative anticipatory responses followed by positive jumps of roughly 0.34 percent when the shocks occur, after which the responses decline. For age 80, the immediate shock produces a positive, hump-shaped response peaking near 0.24 percent. The future shocks produce small negative anticipatory responses and then large positive jumps of roughly 0.43 to 0.46 percent.

Part B, Cohort-specific responses. These panels follow fixed cohorts defined by their age at time zero, so each response ends when that cohort reaches age 100 and exits the model. For the age-30 cohort, shocks in years 20 and 40 lower consumption before they occur, then raise consumption by roughly 0.3 and 0.44 percent, respectively; both responses fall to zero as the cohort exits near year 60. For the age-55 cohort, an immediate shock raises consumption by roughly 0.18 percent, while the year-20 shock first lowers consumption and then raises it by about 0.42 percent. These responses fall rapidly to zero when the cohort exits around years 35-45. A shock in year 40 has no effect because the cohort has already exited. For the age-80 cohort, only the immediate shock matters, raising consumption by about 0.15 percent before the short-lived response ends within roughly 15 years. Shocks in years 20 and 40 occur after this cohort has exited and therefore have zero effect.

Return to text.