Accessible Version

Meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee
June 21-22, 2011 Presentation Materials

Presentation Materials (PDF)

Pages 224 to 282 of the Transcript

Appendix 1: Materials used by Mr. Dotsey

Material for
FOMC Briefing on DSGE Models

Michael Dotsey
June 21, 2011

DSGE Project

Exhibit 1
Overview of Models

  • DSGE = Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium
    • Small to medium size models (smaller than FRB/US, larger than your typical VAR)
    • Models include households, firms, fiscal policy and monetary policy
    • Private agents optimize and are forward-looking
      • Expectations are endogenous
    • General Equilibrium -
      • Prices, wages and interest rates adjust to clear markets
    • Models include economic disturbances (productivity, aggregate demand, policy, etc)
      • Models are estimated
      • Can characterize uncertainty

Exhibit 2
Structure

Firms

  • Employ workers and rent capital
  • Set prices and prices adjust slowly
    • Pricing behavior produces a Phillips Curve
  • Shocks
    • Productivity
    • Price mark-up

Household Sector

  • Own firms and capital
  • Supply labor
  • Make consumption and saving decisions
  • Wages adjust slowly
  • Shocks
    • Efficiency of investment shocks
    • Labor supply shocks
    • Intertemporal Preference Shocks (affect consumption relative to saving)

Policy

  • Fiscal Policy
  • Monetary Policy
  • Shocks
    • Government spending shocks
    • Monetary policy shocks

Exhibit 3

Implementation and Uses

  • Estimation
    • Incorporate priors based on microdata
    • Characterize uncertainty
  • Uses
    • Forecasting
      • Variables used in estimating the model
      • Variables not in the model
      • Nowcasting
    • Identification
      • Identify economic disturbances
    • Alternative policies
      • Structural nature of models lets one analyze alternative policies

Pitfalls

  • Models are relatively small
  • Models are approximations
  • Models lack features important for some applications
  • Some parameters are more policy invariant than others

Exhibit 4
Great Recession - Key Variables

Top-left panel
Year-over-Year Growth

Percent Year-over-Year
Period GDP Consumption Bus Fix Inv
2007:Q11.342.77-3.30
2007:Q21.792.61-1.95
2007:Q32.332.41-0.99
2007:Q42.321.75-0.84
2008:Q11.910.96-2.17
2008:Q21.250.60-4.19
2008:Q3-0.34-0.71-6.89
2008:Q4-2.77-1.88-12.26
2009:Q1-3.80-1.82-20.09
2009:Q2-4.11-2.24-21.28
2009:Q3-2.74-0.89-18.61
2009:Q40.190.18-12.85
2010:Q12.390.78-1.98

Top-right panel
Year-over-Year Hours

Period Percent Year-over-Year
2007:Q11.00
2007:Q21.16
2007:Q30.32
2007:Q4-0.26
2008:Q1-0.56
2008:Q2-1.32
2008:Q3-2.13
2008:Q4-4.32
2009:Q1-6.47
2009:Q2-8.12
2009:Q3-8.18
2009:Q4-5.81
2010:Q1-3.25

Middle-left panel
Core PCE Inflation

Period Percent Log Annualized
2007:Q12.90
2007:Q21.69
2007:Q32.13
2007:Q42.78
2008:Q12.52
2008:Q22.61
2008:Q32.13
2008:Q40.62
2009:Q10.88
2009:Q22.25
2009:Q31.50
2009:Q42.05
2010:Q11.22

Middle-right panel
Spread of Baa to 10yr CMT

Period Percent
2007:Q11.62
2007:Q21.65
2007:Q31.90
2007:Q42.25
2008:Q13.09
2008:Q23.10
2008:Q33.34
2008:Q45.60
2009:Q15.48
2009:Q24.67
2009:Q33.14
2009:Q42.87
2010:Q12.57

Note: The gray shaded bars indicate a period of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research: December 2007-June 2009.

Bottom panel
Great Recession

  • Important for its severity and its lingering effect on current forecasts
  • Above figure displays some key variables
    • Sharpest 4 quarter decline in GDP since Great Depression
    • Decline in BFI especially severe
    • Large and persistent job losses
    • Only a subdued decline in inflation
  • Challenge for models because only New York includes a fully developed financial sector
  • Nevertheless models reach broadly similar conclusions
    • New York model indicates the disturbance was associated with an increase in spreads
    • EDO attributes much of what occurred to an increase in risk premia
    • Chicago and Philadelphia find that investment efficiency shocks and discount rate shocks are the prime drivers
      • These shocks reduce aggregate demand and have a financial interpretation
    • Zero lower bound on interest rates also played a significant role in some of the models

Exhibit 5
Summary Table

Federal Reserve
Bank
Output Growth (Q4/Q4) Inflation (Q4/Q4) Federal Funds Rate (Q4)
2011 2012 2013 2011 2012 2013 2011 2012 2013
Philadelphia3.3
(1.4,6.4)
5.1
(0.9,8.7)
4.7
(0.1,8.3)
1.3
(0.4,2.1)
1.1
(-0.3,2.7)
1.3
(-0.2,3.0)
0.2
(0.0,1.2)
0.6
(0.0,2.4)
1.4
(0.0,3.9)
New York2.1
(0.7,3.2)
2.0
(-1.3,4.6)
1.9
(-1.2,5.2)
1.4
(1.0,1.7)
1.1
(0.3,1.8)
1.5
(0.6,2.3)
0.3
(0.3,1.1)
0.9
(0.3,2.1)
1.8
(0.5,3.3)
Chicago3.1
(.,.)
4.5
(.,.)
4.4
(.,.)
1.4
(.,.)
0.6
(.,.)
0.3
(.,.)
0.1
(.,.)
1.0
(.,.)
2.6
(.,.)
Board of Governors2.8
(1.8,3.5)
2.6
(1.1,3.8)
2.5
(1.1,3.9)
1.5
(1.3,1.7)
1.4
(0.8,1.9)
1.4
(0.8,2.0)
0.4
(0.2,1.4)
1.6
(0.6,2.9)
2.4
(1.1,3.8)
Median Forecast*2.93.53.41.41.11.30.20.92.1

For each individual forecast, the numbers in parentheses represent 68% bands.

* The median forecast is calculated as the median of the Q4/Q4 projections from the forecasters.  Return to table


Exhibit 6
GDP

Top panel

  • Economy is in recovery with 3 models forecasting above trend output growth
    • Philadelphia and Chicago foresee a strong recovery
      • Due to the internal dynamics of models as effects of negative demand shocks dissipate
    • EDO envisions approximately trend growth
    • New York expects slightly below trend growth
      • Financial headwinds have lingering effects in the latter two models

Bottom panel
Real GDP Growth

[Series coincide until 2011:Q2]
Percentage Points (SAAR)
Period Chicago New York Philadelphia Board
2007:Q10.880.880.880.88
2007:Q23.243.243.243.24
2007:Q32.272.272.272.27
2007:Q42.892.892.892.89
2008:Q1-0.73-0.73-0.73-0.73
2008:Q20.600.600.600.60
2008:Q3-4.00-4.00-4.00-4.00
2008:Q4-6.77-6.77-6.77-6.77
2009:Q1-4.87-4.87-4.87-4.87
2009:Q2-0.70-0.70-0.70-0.70
2009:Q31.601.601.601.60
2009:Q45.015.015.015.01
2010:Q13.733.733.733.73
2010:Q21.721.721.721.72
2010:Q32.562.562.562.56
2010:Q43.113.113.113.11
2011:Q11.841.841.841.84
2011:Q22.402.242.432.32
2011:Q33.792.204.163.51
2011:Q44.262.314.643.17
2012:Q14.502.184.912.87
2012:Q24.542.055.012.63
2012:Q34.491.945.002.49
2012:Q44.431.914.942.42
2013:Q14.411.914.842.41
2013:Q24.411.964.722.43
2013:Q34.422.004.582.46
2013:Q44.422.034.442.50

Exhibit 7
Inflation

Top panel

  • Inflation remains subdued over the forecast horizon
    • New York forecasts 1.5% inflation by the end of 2013
    • EDO and Philadelphia expect inflation to be between 1.3% and 1.4% at the end of the forecast horizon
      • In EDO this is a result of labor market slack
    • Chicago projects a sharp decline in inflation

Bottom panel
Core PCE Inflation

[Series coincide until 2011:Q2]
Percentage Points (SAAR)
Period Chicago New York Philadelphia Board
2007:Q12.942.942.942.94
2007:Q21.701.701.701.70
2007:Q32.152.152.152.15
2007:Q42.822.822.822.82
2008:Q12.552.552.552.55
2008:Q22.652.652.652.65
2008:Q32.152.152.152.15
2008:Q40.620.620.620.62
2009:Q10.890.890.890.89
2009:Q22.282.282.282.28
2009:Q31.511.511.511.51
2009:Q42.072.072.072.07
2010:Q11.231.231.231.23
2010:Q21.041.041.041.04
2010:Q30.530.530.530.53
2010:Q40.430.430.430.43
2011:Q11.431.431.431.43
2011:Q21.601.821.681.83
2011:Q31.521.241.131.32
2011:Q41.231.071.061.27
2012:Q10.931.051.071.31
2012:Q20.681.091.111.34
2012:Q30.491.191.141.37
2012:Q40.351.281.181.38
2013:Q10.271.361.221.39
2013:Q20.241.441.251.39
2013:Q30.241.511.281.38
2013:Q40.281.591.321.37

Exhibit 8
Monetary Policy

Top panel

  • Paths for monetary policy are somewhat different but none of the models project significant tightening
    • Philadelphia, NY, and Chicago impose an "extended period" of zero interest rates until mid 2012.
    • By the end of 2012 the models expect the funds rate to be 0.6% (Philadelphia), 0.9% (NY), 1.0% (Chicago), and 1.6% (EDO)
      • The modest to measured policy response is largely due to the benign projections for inflation

Bottom panel
Federal Funds Rate

[Series coincide until 2011:Q2]
Percentage Points
Period Chicago New York Philadelphia Board
2007:Q15.265.265.265.26
2007:Q25.255.255.255.25
2007:Q35.095.095.095.09
2007:Q44.494.494.494.49
2008:Q13.183.183.183.18
2008:Q22.092.092.092.09
2008:Q31.961.961.961.96
2008:Q40.530.530.530.53
2009:Q10.190.190.190.19
2009:Q20.180.180.180.18
2009:Q30.150.150.150.15
2009:Q40.120.120.120.12
2010:Q10.130.130.130.13
2010:Q20.190.190.190.19
2010:Q30.190.190.190.19
2010:Q40.190.190.190.19
2011:Q10.160.160.160.16
2011:Q20.100.090.160.10
2011:Q30.090.250.190.16
2011:Q40.100.250.190.36
2012:Q10.130.250.190.66
2012:Q20.170.240.190.98
2012:Q30.230.600.411.30
2012:Q40.980.870.621.59
2013:Q11.551.110.821.84
2013:Q21.981.341.022.07
2013:Q32.321.551.212.26
2013:Q42.601.751.392.42



Appendix 2: Materials used by Chairman Bernanke

Material for
FOMC Discussion of Exit Strategy Principles

June 21, 2011

Exit Strategy Principles

In light of discussions at the April and June FOMC meetings, the Committee has reached broad agreement on the key elements of the strategy that it expects to follow in normalizing the stance and conduct of monetary policy:

  1. The Committee will determine the timing and pace of policy normalization to promote its statutory mandate of maximum employment and price stability.
  2. To begin the process of policy normalization, the Committee will likely first cease reinvesting some or all payments of principal on the securities holdings in the System Open Market Account (SOMA).
  3. At the same time or relatively soon thereafter, the Committee will modify its forward guidance on the path of the federal funds rate and will initiate temporary reserve-draining operations aimed at supporting the implementation of increases in the federal funds rate when appropriate.
  4. When economic conditions warrant, the Committee's next step in the process of policy normalization will be to begin raising its target for the federal funds rate. [The Committee currently anticipates that the first increase will be three to six months after the modification of the forward guidance.] , and fFrom that point on, changing the level or range of the federal funds rate target will be the primary means of adjusting the stance of monetary policy. During the normalization process, adjustments to the interest rate on excess reserves and to the level of reserves in the banking system will be used to bring the funds rate toward its target.
  5. Sales of agency securities from the SOMA will likely commence sometime after the first increase in the target for the federal funds rate, probably within a few months. The timing and pace of sales will be communicated to the public in advance; that pace is anticipated to be relatively gradual and steady, but it could be adjusted in response to material changes in the economic outlook or financial conditions.
  6. The pace of sales is expected to be aimed at eliminating our holdings of agency securities over a period of four to five years, thereby minimizing the extent to which the SOMA portfolio might affect the allocation of credit across sectors of the economy. Sales at this pace would be expected to normalize the size of the SOMA securities portfolio over a period of about three years. In particular, the size of the securities portfolio and the associated quantity of bank reserves are expected to be reduced to levels that would be consistent with the implementation of monetary policy through the use of conventional open market operations to keep the federal funds rate [near its target | within a corridor defined below by the interest rate paid on excess reserves and above by the primary credit rate].
  7. The Committee is prepared to make adjustments to its exit strategy if necessary in light of economic and financial developments.


Appendix 3: Materials used by Mr. Sack

Material for FOMC Presentation:
Financial Market Developments and Desk Operations

Brian Sack
June 21, 2011

Exhibit 1

Top-left panel
(1)

Title: Implied Federal Funds Rate Path
Series: Future federal funds rates implied by Eurodollar and federal funds futures contracts
Horizon: 4/26/11, 6/17/11
Description: The implied federal funds rate path moved down during the intermeeting period.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Top-right panel
(2)

Title: Probability Distribution of First Increase in Federal Funds Target Rate
Series: April and June Policy Survey
Horizon: 2011:Q2 to 2013:Q1 and later
Description: Survey respondents pushed back their expectations for an increase in the Federal Funds target rate.

Average response from dealer survey.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York Policy Survey

Middle-left panel
(3)

Title: Economic News Index
Series: Citigroup economic surprise index
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: During the intermeeting period the economic surprise index fell drastically.

Positive readings correspond to stronger than expected economic releases.

Source: Citigroup

Middle-right panel
(4)

Title: Treasury Yields
Series: 2-year, 5-year, and 10-year Treasury yields
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: Treasury yields ended the period lower than their levels at the time of the last FOMC meeting.

Source: Bloomberg

Bottom-left panel
(5)

Title: Breakeven Inflation Rates
Series: 5-year spot and 5-year, 5-year forward rates
Horizon: January 1, 2010 - June 17, 2011
Description: Breakeven inflation rates fell during the intermeeting period.

Source: Federal Reserve Board of Governors

Bottom-right panel
(6)

Title: Implied Probability of Deflation over Next Several Years
Series: Deflation probability informed by model based on yields on TIPS maturing in April 2014
Horizon: January 1, 2010 - June 13, 2011
Description: The implied probability of deflation has stayed relatively flat since the last FOMC meeting.

Markets Group deflation probability model based on TIPS security maturing in April 2014.

Source: Barclays Capital, Federal Reserve Bank of New York


Exhibit 2

Top-left panel
(7)

Title: Equities and High Yield Spread
Series: S&P 500 price (indexed to 08/03/09) and Bank of America Merrill Lynch US High Yield Master II Option-Adjusted Spread
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: Equity prices dropped sharply since the previous FOMC meeting, concurrent with a rise in the spread between the high-yield debt yield curve and the Treasury curve.

Source: Bloomberg, Bank of America

Top-right panel
(8)

Title: Non-Agency RMBS Price
Series: 07-01 AAA ABX index
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: Credit default swap prices for non-agency residential mortgage-backed securities have declined since the previous meeting.

Source: JPMorgan Chase

Middle-left panel
(9)

Title: U.S. Bank Index
Series: KBW bank index
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: The index's decline shows perceived weakness in bank stocks.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle-right panel
(10)

Title: Broad Dollar Index
Series: Broad Dollar Index
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: The broad dollar appreciated slightly in the intermeeting period.

Source: Federal Reserve Board of Governors

Bottom-left panel
(11)

Title: Euro Area Sovereign Debt Spreads
Series: Spreads on 2-year Greek bonds & Spanish bonds as compared to Germany
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: The spread on Greek debt rose sharply in the latter portion of the intermeeting period, while the spread on Spanish debt increased only slightly.

Source: Bloomberg

Bottom-right panel
(12)

Title: Libor Spread over OIS (Three-month Rate)
Series: Three-month forward Libor-OIS spread and spot Libor-OIS spread
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: The spot spread between the Libor rate and the overnight index swap rate dropped slightly but largely remained steady at roughly 10 basis points, while the three-month forward spread increased sharply in the last few days of the intermeeting period.

Source: Bloomberg


Exhibit 3

Top-left panel
(13)

Title: Treasury Debt Outstanding
Series: Past and forecast Treasury debt outstanding, and current debt limit
Horizon: October 1, 2010 - October 1, 2011
Description: Treasury reached the current debt limit, and the amount of debt outstanding has flattened accordingly. The current limit will be exceeded after August 2nd.

Source: Federal Reserve Board of Governors

Top-right panel
(14)

Title: Treasury Principal and Interest Payments Due after August 2nd
Series: Marketable Treasury principal and interest payments due
Horizon: August 2, 2011 - August 31, 2011
Description: Treasury has debt payments on the order of hundreds of billions of dollars due in August 2011, most of which is comprised by principal payments.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Middle-left panel
(15)

Title: Treasury Bill Curve
Series: Treasury bill curve
Horizon: June 15, 2011 - December 15, 2011
Description: The Treasury bill term structure is relatively normal, with the market apparently not exhibiting any sharp price increase in bills maturing after the possible debt default date of August 2nd.

Source: Bloomberg

Middle-right panel
(16)

Title: Implied Volatility of Ten-Year Yield (Over Next Three Months)
Series: Implied volatility of ten-year yield over the next three months, derived from swaption prices
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: The volatility of ten-year Treasury yields implied by swaption prices has held steady for the last few months, with a slight uptick in recent weeks.

Source: Barclays Capital

Bottom-left panel
(17) Operational Challenges for SOMA

  • Outright purchases of Treasury securities
  • Rollover of maturing Treasury securities
  • Securities lending activity
  • Ability to conduct repurchase agreements
  • Accounting and reporting of SOMA

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Bottom-right panel
(18)

Title: Short-Term Funding Rates
Series: 5-day moving average of Treasury GC repo, 1-month Treasury bill, and Federal Funds rate
Horizon: August 3, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: While the Federal Funds rate and 1-month Treasury bill rate have remained steady since the previous FOMC meeting (with a rise and subsequent fall in the Treasury bill rate), the haircut on Treasury general collateral used in repurchase agreements has increased.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York


Exhibit 4

Top-left panel
(19)

Title: SOMA Purchases of Treasury Securities
Series: Past and projected SOMA purchases of Treasury securities through LSAP 2 and reinvestments
Horizon: June 2010 - December 2011
Description: The SOMA purchase schedule continues as planned, with LSAP 2 purchases complete at the end of June and reinvestments from principal repayment continuing after this date.

*Projection reflects assumption that reinvestments continue through year end.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Top-right panel
(20) Proposed Distribution of Reinvestments Compared to LSAP 2

LSAP 2 Reinvestments
Maturity Allocation Maturity Allocation
1.5 to 2.55%1.5 to 2.55%
2.5 to 420%2.5 to 420%
4 to 5.520%4 to 5.520%
5.5 to 723%5.5 to 723%
7 to 1023%7 to 1023%
10 to 172% 10 to 306%
17 to 304%
TIPS3%TIPS3%

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

Middle-left panel
(21)

Title: SOMA Holdings as a Percent of Outstanding
Series: Past and current SOMA holdings as a percent of outstanding Treasury debt
Horizon: January 3, 2007 - June 17, 2011
Description: SOMA holdings as a percentage of outstanding Treasury debt have ticked up significantly in recent months given the continuation of the LSAP program.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York, U.S. Department of Treasury

Middle-right panel
(22)

Title: 10-Year Treasury Bid-Ask Spread
Series: Bid-ask spread for on-the-run 10-year Treasury
Horizon: June 23, 2009 - June 17, 2011
Description: Aside from a momentary spike early in the LSAP 2 period, the bid-ask spread has remained relatively constant since the announcement of the purchase program in November, indicating that these purchases have not had noticeably detrimental effects in the liquidity or functioning of the market for Treasuries.

Source: BrokerTec

Bottom-left panel
(23)

Title: Probability of Asset Purchases and Sales over 2-Year Horizon
Series: Probability of Treasury and MBS purchases and sales: June survey median, June survey interquartile range, and March survey median
Horizon: March 2011, June 2011
Description: Surveyed market participants believe there is a low probability of any new policy initiative to purchase more MBS or Treasuries, while their assessments of the probability of Treasury and MBS sales have increased since March (especially for MBS).

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York Policy Survey

Bottom-right panel
(24)

Title: Expected Size of Domestic Assets in SOMA
Series: Estimates of size of SOMA from Tealbook, June survey median, and June survey interquartile range
Horizon: End-of-year 2009 - End-of-year 2015
Description: Tealbook estimates and June policy survey estimates track quite closely over the coming years, and there is broad agreement that the end of 2011 will mark the balance sheet's high point for the near future.

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York Policy Survey



Appendix 4: Materials used by Mr. Slifman, Ms. Wilson, Mr. Reeve, and Mr. Covitz

Material for Staff Presentation on the Economic Outlook

June 21-22, 2011

Exhibit 1
Recent Indicators

Top-left panel
Change in Private Payroll Employment

Period Thousands of employees Three-month moving average
January 2007190ND
February 200758ND
March 2007200149.33
April 200757105.00
May 2007111122.67
June 20075072.67
July 20071759.33
August 2007-95-9.33
September 20075-24.33
October 200774-5.33
November 20079859.00
December 20073870.00
January 2008446.67
February 2008-128-28.67
March 2008-87-70.33
April 2008-186-133.67
May 2008-240-171.00
June 2008-217-214.33
July 2008-265-240.67
August 2008-317-266.33
September 2008-434-338.67
October 2008-491-414.00
November 2008-787-570.67
December 2008-636-638.00
January 2009-841-754.67
February 2009-721-732.67
March 2009-787-783.00
April 2009-773-760.33
May 2009-326-628.67
June 2009-438-512.33
July 2009-287-350.33
August 2009-215-313.33
September 2009-213-238.33
October 2009-250-226.00
November 2009-34-165.67
December 2009-102-128.67
January 2010-42-59.33
February 2010-21-55.00
March 201014427.00
April 2010229117.33
May 201048140.33
June 201065114.00
July 20109368.67
August 201011089.33
September 2010109104.00
October 2010143120.67
November 2010128126.67
December 2010167146.00
January 201194129.67
February 2011261174.00
March 2011219191.33
April 2011251243.67
May 201183184.33

Top-right panel
Manufacturing IP

Percent change, annual rate
Period April Tealbook June Tealbook
2010:Q3ND5.1
2010:Q4ND3.4
2011:Q19.16.5
Forecast
2011:Q25.01.4

Middle-left panel
Consumer Spending

  • News for consumer outlays disappointing.
  • Revised down level of real DPI nearly $70 billion in Q1.
  • Consumer sentiment remains low.
  • Real PCE up at only a 1½ percent rate in Q2.

Middle-right panel
Business Conditions Index

Diffusion index
Period ISM-PMI Empire State Philadelphia
January 200749.956.0252.45
February 200752.061.1351.85
March 200751.354.0452.70
April 200752.653.6852.75
May 200752.355.7254.20
June 200752.459.1557.25
July 200751.760.9653.90
August 200750.260.4351.10
September 200750.055.6255.25
October 200750.960.6551.85
November 200751.561.2352.40
December 200749.055.3254.85
January 200851.150.8844.30
February 200848.948.1145.90
March 200849.048.9448.10
April 200848.850.2843.00
May 200848.850.4848.75
June 200849.048.0740.80
July 200849.651.4342.50
August 200848.047.9341.45
September 200843.849.8051.55
October 200838.438.9335.10
November 200836.939.4033.85
December 200833.338.4035.55
January 200935.738.4339.85
February 200936.038.7335.50
March 200936.628.1132.45
April 200939.947.5838.95
May 200941.945.8238.80
June 200944.745.9344.20
July 200949.051.9847.45
August 200951.456.2651.05
September 200953.258.4851.30
October 200955.864.1954.00
November 200954.758.3655.50
December 200956.451.1252.35
January 201058.360.1654.00
February 201057.156.7161.15
March 201060.462.0956.20
April 201059.664.0557.00
May 201057.857.4953.25
June 201055.358.7852.90
July 201055.154.6547.75
August 201055.249.6046.25
September 201055.351.9446.30
October 201056.955.0148.35
November 201058.238.1054.00
December 201058.551.0255.30
January 201160.856.2061.80
February 201161.455.9061.85
March 201161.252.9170.15
April 201160.461.1759.40
May 201153.558.6052.70
June 2011ND46.1146.15

Bottom-left panel
Transitory Influences on GDP Growth Rate

  • Effects of the disasters in Japan on U.S. production of motor vehicles and parts.
  • Higher price of imported oil.
  • Temporary drop in defense purchases.

Bottom-right panel
GDP Projection

(Percent change, annual rate)
2011
Q1 Q2 Q3
1.Real GDP2.11.93.9
2.Apr. TB1.73.14.1
Excluding earthquake effects
3.Real GDP 2.72.9
4.Apr. TB 3.43.6

Exhibit 2
Sluggish Recovery


Top-left panel
Real GDP

Peak = 100
Quarter, from
NBER peak
Peak 1973:Q4 Peak 1981:Q3 Peak 2007:Q4,
Jan. 2010 TB
Peak 2007:Q4,
Current
0100.00100.00100.00100.00
199.1298.7599.8299.82
299.3897.1399.9799.97
398.3997.6698.9598.95
498.0197.2897.2397.23
596.8197.3696.0396.03
697.5598.5795.8695.86
799.20100.7996.2496.24
8100.49102.7797.4297.42
Forecast
9102.78104.9098.0998.32
10103.55106.9399.0298.74
11104.06108.7899.9699.36
12104.81109.84100.94100.13
13106.03110.73102.00100.59
Forecast
14108.14111.78103.19101.13
15110.07112.72104.43102.11
16110.05114.48105.71102.84

Top-right panel
Real PCE

Peak = 100
Quarter, from
NBER peak
Peak 1973:Q4 Peak 1981:Q3 Peak 2007:Q4,
Jan. 2010 TB
Peak 2007:Q4,
Current
0100.00100.00100.00100.00
199.1299.2499.8199.81
299.4799.8999.8399.83
399.88100.2498.9498.94
498.42101.0198.1298.12
599.24102.8597.9997.99
6100.90103.8697.5997.59
7102.33105.9398.0798.07
8103.42107.8098.2998.29
Forecast
9105.49109.5198.9698.75
10106.45110.4499.6399.29
11107.58112.02100.3599.88
12108.98112.89101.05100.86
13110.23114.38101.87101.41
Forecast
14110.84116.32102.78101.81
15111.89117.38103.77102.46
16113.58119.61104.80103.08

Middle-left panel
Real Residential Construction

Peak = 100
Quarter, from
NBER peak
Peak 1973:Q4 Peak 1981:Q3 Peak 2007:Q4,
Jan. 2010 TB
Peak 2007:Q4,
Current
0100.00100.00100.00100.00
192.6789.7692.1592.15
288.6384.5888.7588.75
385.7081.9183.2483.24
474.4381.6575.4375.43
569.8387.6367.4067.40
671.33102.5763.8163.81
776.30114.7265.4365.43
879.64126.0865.3065.30
Forecast
987.78131.4165.5163.19
1090.30135.0667.5666.90
1188.83137.5666.8761.78
12100.15136.2468.8362.28
13103.17136.3871.9261.82
Forecast
14114.98135.9676.5662.21
15114.61137.0581.4162.84
16113.10138.7885.9262.95

Middle-right panel
Real Equipment and Software

Peak = 100
Quarter, from
NBER peak
Peak 1973:Q4 Peak 1981:Q3 Peak 2007:Q4,
Jan. 2010 TB
Peak 2007:Q4,
Current
0100.00100.00100.00100.00
1100.1799.11100.74100.74
2100.0697.3799.1999.19
3100.7493.6796.3096.30
497.0491.9688.2488.24
590.5490.2980.2680.26
688.7489.9880.2980.29
789.7294.6081.1281.12
890.96100.1183.9383.93
Forecast
992.17108.7185.6387.92
1094.04110.8288.3192.92
1196.67116.2991.6096.31
1299.44120.2094.7298.12
13105.43124.0498.16100.51
Forecast
14108.04123.32101.51102.23
15110.61126.17104.95105.46
16115.74124.63108.38107.89

Bottom-left panel
Why is Consumer Spending So Sluggish?

  • One-fourth of mortgage borrowers underwater.
  • Few resources available to smooth consumption.
  • Reduced income expectations; higher precautionary saving.

Bottom-right panel
Median Expected Change in Family Income

Period Three-month moving average
January 19853.33
February 19853.00
March 19852.67
April 19852.63
May 19852.57
June 19852.90
July 19852.87
August 19853.03
September 19852.83
October 19852.83
November 19852.77
December 19852.93
January 19863.10
February 19863.17
March 19862.97
April 19863.10
May 19863.10
June 19863.17
July 19863.20
August 19863.27
September 19863.23
October 19863.23
November 19863.23
December 19863.23
January 19873.13
February 19872.93
March 19872.57
April 19872.50
May 19872.47
June 19872.77
July 19872.67
August 19872.93
September 19872.77
October 19872.93
November 19873.10
December 19873.27
January 19883.17
February 19883.17
March 19883.37
April 19883.13
May 19882.73
June 19882.53
July 19882.90
August 19883.40
September 19883.67
October 19883.53
November 19883.50
December 19883.40
January 19893.47
February 19893.33
March 19893.17
April 19893.27
May 19893.10
June 19893.07
July 19892.77
August 19892.87
September 19892.93
October 19893.30
November 19893.50
December 19893.70
January 19903.60
February 19903.20
March 19903.10
April 19903.37
May 19903.50
June 19903.47
July 19903.40
August 19903.30
September 19903.17
October 19902.70
November 19902.60
December 19902.57
January 19912.67
February 19912.60
March 19912.73
April 19912.70
May 19912.33
June 19912.33
July 19912.30
August 19912.40
September 19912.30
October 19912.40
November 19912.80
December 19912.73
January 19922.33
February 19922.00
March 19921.80
April 19922.20
May 19922.37
June 19922.67
July 19922.20
August 19922.07
September 19922.10
October 19922.47
November 19922.80
December 19922.93
January 19933.03
February 19932.93
March 19932.40
April 19932.10
May 19932.03
June 19932.30
July 19932.33
August 19932.10
September 19932.27
October 19932.43
November 19932.83
December 19932.63
January 19942.37
February 19942.23
March 19942.13
April 19942.47
May 19942.43
June 19942.50
July 19942.17
August 19942.03
September 19942.17
October 19942.43
November 19942.60
December 19942.63
January 19952.70
February 19952.67
March 19952.53
April 19952.33
May 19952.37
June 19952.47
July 19952.60
August 19952.63
September 19952.43
October 19952.43
November 19952.37
December 19952.40
January 19962.43
February 19962.37
March 19962.63
April 19962.53
May 19962.50
June 19962.23
July 19962.30
August 19962.47
September 19962.73
October 19962.80
November 19962.77
December 19962.63
January 19972.63
February 19972.77
March 19972.77
April 19972.73
May 19972.67
June 19972.70
July 19972.70
August 19972.60
September 19972.43
October 19972.47
November 19972.57
December 19972.73
January 19982.70
February 19982.83
March 19982.70
April 19982.70
May 19982.47
June 19982.57
July 19982.60
August 19982.73
September 19982.87
October 19982.77
November 19982.70
December 19982.67
January 19992.73
February 19992.77
March 19992.77
April 19992.73
May 19992.77
June 19992.90
July 19993.03
August 19993.17
September 19993.13
October 19993.13
November 19993.03
December 19992.90
January 20002.97
February 20003.00
March 20003.17
April 20003.10
May 20003.07
June 20003.00
July 20003.00
August 20003.00
September 20003.10
October 20003.07
November 20003.13
December 20003.00
January 20012.97
February 20012.93
March 20013.00
April 20012.90
May 20012.87
June 20012.63
July 20012.53
August 20012.47
September 20012.27
October 20012.10
November 20011.90
December 20012.27
January 20022.57
February 20022.87
March 20022.67
April 20022.70
May 20022.57
June 20022.73
July 20022.87
August 20022.83
September 20022.80
October 20022.60
November 20022.57
December 20022.60
January 20032.53
February 20032.40
March 20032.33
April 20032.37
May 20032.53
June 20032.53
July 20032.80
August 20032.73
September 20032.67
October 20032.27
November 20032.33
December 20032.43
January 20042.67
February 20042.67
March 20042.67
April 20042.47
May 20042.43
June 20042.43
July 20042.57
August 20042.63
September 20042.53
October 20042.43
November 20042.43
December 20042.57
January 20052.80
February 20052.77
March 20052.63
April 20052.33
May 20052.23
June 20052.03
July 20052.27
August 20052.20
September 20052.33
October 20052.27
November 20052.33
December 20052.57
January 20062.50
February 20062.47
March 20062.17
April 20062.23
May 20062.13
June 20062.23
July 20062.13
August 20062.27
September 20062.13
October 20062.37
November 20062.50
December 20062.77
January 20072.70
February 20072.67
March 20072.67
April 20072.63
May 20072.50
June 20072.37
July 20072.37
August 20072.47
September 20072.40
October 20072.30
November 20072.33
December 20072.40
January 20082.40
February 20082.17
March 20082.23
April 20081.80
May 20081.83
June 20081.60
July 20081.93
August 20082.00
September 20082.20
October 20081.93
November 20081.67
December 20081.07
January 20090.83
February 20090.50
March 20090.37
April 20090.30
May 20090.23
June 20090.30
July 20090.27
August 20090.33
September 20090.27
October 20090.30
November 20090.27
December 20090.37
January 20100.37
February 20100.33
March 20100.27
April 20100.27
May 20100.30
June 20100.30
July 20100.27
August 20100.27
September 20100.30
October 20100.33
November 20100.37
December 20100.37
January 20110.33
February 20110.27
March 20110.20
April 20110.23
May 20110.27

Note: Expected family income change during the next 12 months. The gray shaded bars indicate a period of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research: July 1990-March 1991, March 2001-November 2001, and December 2007-June 2009.

Source: Thompson Reuters/University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers.


Exhibit 3
Medium-term Forecast

Top-left panel
Real GDP

Percent change, annual rate
Period April Tealbook June Tealbook
2011:H1*2.62.4
2011:H2*3.83.0
20124.23.5

* Excluding earthquake effects.  Return to table

Top-right panel
Unemployment Rate

Percent
Period April Tealbook Current
2007:Q1ND4.50
2007:Q2ND4.50
2007:Q3ND4.70
2007:Q4ND4.80
2008:Q1ND5.00
2008:Q2ND5.30
2008:Q3ND6.00
2008:Q4ND6.90
2009:Q1ND8.20
2009:Q2ND9.30
2009:Q3ND9.70
2009:Q4ND10.00
2010:Q1ND9.70
2010:Q2ND9.60
2010:Q3ND9.60
2010:Q4ND9.60
2011:Q18.938.93
Forecast
2011:Q28.859.02
2011:Q38.789.00
2011:Q48.688.86
2012:Q18.458.79
2012:Q28.198.63
2012:Q37.938.42
2012:Q47.668.13

Middle-left panel
Factors Influencing Contour of the Forecast

Positives

  • Accommodative montary policy, lower dollar, increasing credit availability, waning effects of earlier wealth declines.
  • Household and business confidence recuperate.

But…

  • Impetus may be smaller than previously thought.

Middle-right panel
Equipment and Software Capital Stock

Period Percent change, Q4/Q4
19602.90
19612.21
19623.47
19634.04
19645.28
19657.25
19668.60
19676.64
19686.48
19696.74
19705.17
19714.28
19725.35
19737.30
19746.30
19753.44
19763.67
19775.08
19786.44
19796.60
19804.48
19814.18
19822.14
19832.22
19844.28
19853.99
19863.16
19872.46
19882.95
19893.19
19902.40
19911.48
19921.90
19933.24
19944.24
19955.05
19965.49
19976.17
19986.91
19997.41
20007.39
20014.42
20022.57
20032.25
20042.85
20053.48
20064.14
20073.87
20082.40
2009-0.83
20101.41
Forecast
20112.75
20123.48

Bottom-left panel
Real PCE

Percent change, annual rate
Period April Tealbook June Tealbook
2009ND0.18
2010ND2.61
Forecast
20112.922.20
20123.732.79

Bottom-right panel
Single-family Housing Starts

Millions
Period April Tealbook Current
2007:Q1ND1.17
2007:Q2ND1.15
2007:Q3ND0.98
2007:Q4ND0.84
2008:Q1ND0.74
2008:Q2ND0.67
2008:Q3ND0.59
2008:Q4ND0.47
2009:Q1ND0.36
2009:Q2ND0.43
2009:Q3ND0.50
2009:Q4ND0.49
2010:Q1ND0.52
2010:Q2ND0.49
2010:Q3ND0.43
2010:Q4ND0.44
2011:Q10.410.41
Forecast
2011:Q20.420.41
2011:Q30.440.42
2011:Q40.450.42
2012:Q10.470.43
2012:Q20.480.44
2012:Q30.520.47
2012:Q40.560.50

Exhibit 4
Inflation Projection

Top-left panel
Reserve Bank Inquiries of Their District Business Contacts

Question Percent
Plan to increase employment45
Skill shortages restraining hiring21
Raise starting pay for recruiting6
Expected wage change less than 2.5 percent*56

* Includes underchanged and decrease.  Return to table

Top-right panel
Compensation per Hour*

Period Percent change, Q4/Q4
2005-073.87
20082.30
20092.80
20101.36
Forecast
20112.11
20122.49

* Nonfarm business sector.  Return to text

Middle-left panel
PCE Price Projection

(Percent change, Q4/Q4)
2011 2012
H1 H2
1.PCE price index3.61.11.5
2.Apr. TB3.31.21.2
3.Food6.52.51.4
4.Energy28.9-6.11.0
5.Core PCE1.81.61.5
6.Apr. TB1.51.31.4

Middle-right panel
Retail Price of Gasoline

Date Dollars per gallon
10 January 20113.14
17 January 20113.12
24 January 20113.13
31 January 20113.14
7 February 20113.18
14 February 20113.21
21 February 20113.26
28 February 20113.44
7 March 20113.57
14 March 20113.60
21 March 20113.59
28 March 20113.63
4 April 20113.73
11 April 20113.84
18 April 20113.89
25 April 20113.89
2 May 20113.93
9 May 20113.89
16 May 20113.84
23 May 20113.71
30 May 20113.66
6 June 20113.65
13 June 20113.58

Note: Seasonally adjusted price of regular unleaded gasoline.

Bottom-left panel
Unemployment Rate

Percent
Period Unemployment rate NAIRU* NAIRU with EEB**
2007:Q14.515.00ND
2007:Q24.495.00ND
2007:Q34.675.00ND
2007:Q44.815.00ND
2008:Q14.965.005.00
2008:Q25.325.005.00
2008:Q36.045.175.30
2008:Q46.915.335.48
2009:Q18.215.495.76
2009:Q29.275.666.03
2009:Q39.675.826.35
2009:Q49.995.996.60
2010:Q19.695.996.74
2010:Q29.655.996.64
2010:Q39.585.996.64
2010:Q49.625.996.59
2011:Q18.936.006.55
Forecast
2011:Q29.026.006.57
2011:Q39.006.006.55
2011:Q48.866.006.54
2012:Q18.796.006.48
2012:Q28.636.006.37
2012:Q38.426.006.26
2012:Q48.136.006.15

As shown in the chart, when unemployment rate is above NAIRU with EEB, the region between them is shaded light tan and is labeled "Labor market slack." When unemployment rate is below NAIRU, the region between them is shaded light gray.

* Staff estimate.  Return to table

** Emergency unemployment compensation and state-federal extended benefits programs.  Return to table

Bottom-right panel
Inflation Expectations

Percent
Period Next twelve months Next five to ten years
January 20042.72.8
February 20042.62.9
March 20042.92.9
April 20043.22.7
May 20043.32.8
June 20043.32.9
July 20043.02.8
August 20042.82.7
September 20042.82.8
October 20043.12.8
November 20042.82.7
December 20043.02.8
January 20052.92.7
February 20052.92.8
March 20053.22.9
April 20053.33.0
May 20053.22.9
June 20053.22.8
July 20053.02.9
August 20053.12.8
September 20054.33.1
October 20054.63.2
November 20053.33.0
December 20053.13.1
January 20063.02.9
February 20063.02.9
March 20063.02.9
April 20063.33.1
May 20064.03.2
June 20063.32.9
July 20063.22.9
August 20063.83.2
September 20063.13.0
October 20063.13.1
November 20063.03.0
December 20062.93.0
January 20073.03.0
February 20073.02.9
March 20073.02.9
April 20073.33.1
May 20073.33.1
June 20073.42.9
July 20073.43.1
August 20073.22.9
September 20073.12.9
October 20073.12.8
November 20073.42.9
December 20073.43.1
January 20083.43.0
February 20083.63.0
March 20084.32.9
April 20084.83.2
May 20085.23.4
June 20085.13.4
July 20085.13.2
August 20084.83.2
September 20084.33.0
October 20083.92.9
November 20082.92.9
December 20081.72.6
January 20092.22.9
February 20091.93.1
March 20092.02.6
April 20092.82.8
May 20092.82.9
June 20093.13.0
July 20092.93.0
August 20092.82.8
September 20092.22.8
October 20092.92.9
November 20092.73.0
December 20092.52.7
January 20102.82.9
February 20102.72.7
March 20102.72.7
April 20102.92.7
May 20103.22.9
June 20102.82.8
July 20102.72.9
August 20102.72.8
September 20102.22.7
October 20102.72.8
November 20103.02.8
December 20103.02.8
January 20113.42.9
February 20113.42.9
March 20114.63.2
April 20114.62.9
May 20114.12.9
June 20114.03.0

Source: Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers.


Exhibit 5
Europe

Top-left panel
10-year Sovereign Bonds Spreads*

Basis points
Date Greece Ireland Portugal Spain Italy Belgium
1 October 200889.358.767.855.583.759.4
2 October 200889.858.266.755.682.659.6
3 October 200886.758.464.555.180.056.7
6 October 200889.258.965.855.382.356.5
7 October 200890.959.466.056.082.956.3
8 October 200894.459.469.460.085.656.2
9 October 200897.060.670.060.886.157.1
10 October 200899.263.370.564.087.360.3
13 October 200893.565.466.362.080.658.6
14 October 200886.161.656.956.074.053.9
15 October 200883.659.949.447.268.746.7
16 October 200885.460.350.847.570.547.1
17 October 200888.260.253.149.172.947.5
20 October 200889.260.552.049.272.047.5
21 October 200892.160.353.848.375.347.3
22 October 2008100.665.558.152.182.251.1
23 October 2008108.370.563.456.487.754.8
24 October 2008115.574.368.961.892.357.6
27 October 2008119.979.772.261.896.257.8
28 October 2008122.183.272.761.6100.160.9
29 October 2008149.087.081.763.7111.664.9
30 October 2008157.889.688.167.7121.369.7
31 October 2008161.296.092.470.7124.873.0
3 November 2008164.6101.593.371.5119.674.7
4 November 2008154.6102.293.672.6106.975.8
5 November 2008150.498.590.368.2101.673.9
6 November 2008151.097.286.362.896.873.4
7 November 2008140.192.977.056.292.869.5
10 November 2008136.883.375.656.091.568.2
11 November 2008139.384.175.155.394.967.4
12 November 2008146.685.878.155.1103.365.5
13 November 2008151.185.378.555.8105.165.8
14 November 2008138.578.070.046.294.757.4
17 November 2008146.779.172.349.6102.058.6
18 November 2008142.779.371.049.1100.560.8
19 November 2008143.879.371.849.8101.061.8
20 November 2008146.282.571.647.9104.064.1
21 November 2008150.483.873.549.8107.168.1
24 November 2008149.287.374.452.6105.971.5
25 November 2008154.887.575.055.1108.971.6
26 November 2008157.988.975.058.9111.771.5
27 November 2008161.188.175.960.5116.571.6
28 November 2008158.190.877.063.2120.472.9
1 December 2008166.294.480.870.4125.678.0
2 December 2008164.3101.680.471.6126.478.5
3 December 2008163.1103.479.471.2125.876.7
4 December 2008167.0103.485.876.0133.078.7
5 December 2008168.5113.591.478.0140.781.0
8 December 2008169.1116.993.379.9137.982.7
9 December 2008167.9117.991.678.6130.783.5
10 December 2008169.7118.392.578.4126.982.8
11 December 2008191.1118.890.777.0127.780.0
12 December 2008206.5121.493.277.6132.280.0
15 December 2008220.6130.699.181.3137.483.2
16 December 2008219.2127.297.482.8132.583.6
17 December 2008223.9127.796.184.3134.183.6
18 December 2008228.2130.096.184.5134.883.0
19 December 2008225.9129.996.383.8135.882.6
22 December 2008230.7131.2100.585.1137.183.4
23 December 2008228.0131.6100.885.5134.682.8
24 December 2008226.5132.8101.285.4134.882.9
25 December 2008226.6133.5100.785.5134.982.9
26 December 2008227.1133.5100.785.5134.982.9
29 December 2008228.9132.1102.485.1141.482.3
30 December 2008227.8130.9102.686.6142.683.0
31 December 2008227.4131.5102.286.0143.182.4
1 January 2009227.5131.6103.286.1143.182.6
2 January 2009223.1128.7100.783.7135.979.0
5 January 2009214.7127.599.983.4130.779.2
6 January 2009215.0139.3101.583.4130.380.4
7 January 2009211.0138.396.679.8124.679.7
8 January 2009212.1138.898.379.3125.881.7
9 January 2009225.6142.799.282.5131.486.3
12 January 2009234.6155.3107.290.9138.689.3
13 January 2009239.1156.7112.998.5140.794.7
14 January 2009244.6163.7116.7100.9146.396.1
15 January 2009253.8173.5129.8114.7151.999.5
16 January 2009251.9185.0127.3118.8146.9117.2
19 January 2009251.7207.2125.5115.6142.5118.4
20 January 2009268.4226.5137.7117.9149.5121.2
21 January 2009278.4264.6146.2123.3156.8130.8
22 January 2009291.4272.5159.1121.3154.5137.7
23 January 2009296.8271.7151.4118.2155.2134.3
26 January 2009285.2269.8141.9115.0151.0131.3
27 January 2009276.7254.0140.0113.7158.6125.6
28 January 2009266.1234.2133.5113.1153.4119.1
29 January 2009247.2221.8125.4109.5142.4112.5
30 January 2009251.9222.0129.2109.8141.8110.6
2 February 2009251.4215.6127.9110.2134.2111.1
3 February 2009244.8214.8123.7105.5127.3108.0
4 February 2009232.6208.3110.594.8116.894.7
5 February 2009236.3200.5110.792.4122.895.3
6 February 2009233.5199.4108.9110.4119.795.2
9 February 2009222.5194.0103.2100.1114.293.8
10 February 2009229.0192.5105.299.9118.793.1
11 February 2009247.4202.9120.5103.6132.599.7
12 February 2009264.2223.2129.8116.6140.8106.0
13 February 2009274.6234.9137.8116.9147.1107.7
16 February 2009291.4247.8155.7125.4154.7120.1
17 February 2009299.0253.6163.0128.0157.5124.8
18 February 2009291.2252.2158.8121.7150.7119.3
19 February 2009268.0242.5146.1119.5140.2116.6
20 February 2009250.5237.0143.1115.0142.1116.1
23 February 2009239.6233.7147.7112.9143.1110.7
24 February 2009248.3239.3154.5117.6151.6112.7
25 February 2009245.9241.5147.2117.7157.2111.3
26 February 2009245.5237.5147.7118.0154.6109.4
27 February 2009256.6239.3146.7117.2156.9108.7
2 March 2009258.7245.7149.7118.1156.7109.5
3 March 2009267.0248.0146.9116.0156.0108.4
4 March 2009269.3254.3142.5109.2149.8104.6
5 March 2009272.4255.6140.2104.7149.4104.6
6 March 2009280.6267.4150.0110.2156.1108.5
9 March 2009275.8269.3150.8106.3152.4108.0
10 March 2009275.1266.3149.6104.1149.4105.8
11 March 2009269.0274.2145.2100.1145.5102.6
12 March 2009300.3277.8149.8102.5151.6101.1
13 March 2009297.9277.3164.9100.4145.898.5
16 March 2009294.1274.3155.798.2137.191.1
17 March 2009281.3274.4153.199.1133.391.1
18 March 2009275.3275.8153.399.5131.190.0
19 March 2009275.9283.5157.7104.8134.391.8
20 March 2009265.9275.8152.3104.7128.889.0
23 March 2009261.7272.6152.8102.4131.988.1
24 March 2009260.2248.0150.2100.8130.187.9
25 March 2009249.3234.7145.598.5124.886.7
26 March 2009251.9224.6141.895.1125.186.4
27 March 2009256.8228.8145.996.3128.187.3
30 March 2009271.8237.7151.7103.0140.192.7
31 March 2009274.6246.9155.9105.7140.094.9
1 April 2009271.2238.9155.1106.2134.496.3
2 April 2009260.2226.2148.5100.6127.591.3
3 April 2009248.7208.6139.094.0118.383.9
6 April 2009241.4201.7134.187.9118.176.9
7 April 2009243.8204.2137.991.6122.679.4
8 April 2009238.8213.2138.893.5122.677.9
9 April 2009230.4214.6135.390.8118.375.7
10 April 2009230.2215.3136.789.6117.675.5
13 April 2009229.9214.7137.689.1117.475.7
14 April 2009231.8216.0136.990.2119.375.2
15 April 2009232.7221.1138.792.2118.975.2
16 April 2009227.2209.1136.489.0114.574.1
17 April 2009221.7208.6131.986.0109.571.7
20 April 2009222.9208.8132.886.2115.772.8
21 April 2009232.3210.8136.786.9119.774.0
22 April 2009221.1209.9132.982.4115.771.3
23 April 2009211.0197.4121.278.6108.767.0
24 April 2009212.1198.0123.681.6111.969.8
27 April 2009214.5203.7123.882.0113.570.2
28 April 2009215.3205.8123.581.5115.370.6
29 April 2009218.6205.1120.377.4114.370.4
30 April 2009214.0202.1114.774.8109.969.0
1 May 2009214.6203.4114.674.9110.669.1
4 May 2009209.0198.2103.871.6101.066.1
5 May 2009201.2189.799.469.898.463.7
6 May 2009198.5186.694.068.896.262.8
7 May 2009174.0170.184.864.785.159.1
8 May 2009162.5163.880.559.480.556.3
11 May 2009169.0166.979.859.384.057.4
12 May 2009179.5172.679.661.591.161.3
13 May 2009186.7175.889.362.996.764.3
14 May 2009192.8185.495.869.1101.669.8
15 May 2009179.5180.783.367.592.966.9
18 May 2009178.5180.982.767.493.366.8
19 May 2009170.0177.278.067.488.063.7
20 May 2009167.8176.679.366.686.962.3
21 May 2009176.5182.888.274.293.865.9
22 May 2009168.2172.478.565.882.155.8
25 May 2009166.8170.774.967.380.056.7
26 May 2009171.2171.077.767.282.756.1
27 May 2009173.4175.875.865.583.555.3
28 May 2009182.5177.077.867.088.456.7
29 May 2009185.7186.682.569.689.459.2
1 June 2009183.5184.578.568.982.557.9
2 June 2009183.0184.278.975.585.055.5
3 June 2009187.3192.985.576.390.256.4
4 June 2009192.8201.394.081.294.059.8
5 June 2009186.2199.491.074.289.657.2
8 June 2009185.7201.791.873.0101.056.5
9 June 2009189.0206.094.673.4105.256.6
10 June 2009183.9202.891.273.4104.856.2
11 June 2009177.3199.990.173.1104.256.9
12 June 2009171.9194.192.274.9105.357.4
15 June 2009171.2196.794.677.9108.058.9
16 June 2009172.1195.996.079.7109.858.8
17 June 2009176.3195.797.382.3111.059.3
18 June 2009176.2196.996.479.4108.058.5
19 June 2009175.0220.196.077.1108.057.3
22 June 2009182.0223.699.079.0113.057.6
23 June 2009186.2229.6102.378.0114.958.6
24 June 2009180.1241.7100.975.4111.758.6
25 June 2009176.2244.6101.674.1111.657.7
26 June 2009175.7244.8102.675.2111.759.0
29 June 2009168.0239.1102.174.8106.358.6
30 June 2009165.5234.4100.974.5104.857.6
1 July 2009162.7229.799.073.7102.756.8
2 July 2009160.2229.1101.372.9105.658.0
3 July 2009NDNDNDNDNDND
6 July 2009157.8219.2103.373.6108.659.6
7 July 2009159.6217.1100.973.8110.758.2
8 July 2009173.0222.5106.778.3115.661.1
9 July 2009169.9222.8101.378.4116.361.4
10 July 2009174.1222.4100.978.7118.862.3
13 July 2009174.2222.4103.380.1118.962.4
14 July 2009171.0219.6101.478.9116.361.6
15 July 2009162.6210.196.175.3109.157.9
16 July 2009158.7210.496.074.8107.657.4
17 July 2009154.9211.491.873.8101.056.1
20 July 2009142.9201.784.465.995.153.7
21 July 2009140.3200.783.464.094.954.1
22 July 2009139.8196.980.162.593.551.4
23 July 2009132.5181.474.758.389.448.2
24 July 2009138.5176.470.657.590.247.8
27 July 2009135.9174.966.857.085.945.9
28 July 2009130.8173.467.957.385.645.4
29 July 2009124.2168.061.856.784.045.2
30 July 2009119.1164.059.354.682.344.0
31 July 2009122.0166.462.854.686.043.4
3 August 2009119.9166.162.054.882.843.7
4 August 2009119.9162.161.355.181.744.3
5 August 2009116.6161.159.456.480.844.8
6 August 2009114.7160.260.455.378.945.0
7 August 2009110.2151.654.449.270.340.8
10 August 2009107.9142.552.144.666.935.2
11 August 2009109.1144.552.944.871.536.6
12 August 2009113.3150.258.747.473.638.3
13 August 2009116.3150.259.546.977.240.2
14 August 2009120.7154.363.651.482.445.6
17 August 2009126.2155.065.053.683.847.9
18 August 2009123.7154.962.951.681.848.4
19 August 2009130.1158.065.753.785.850.3
20 August 2009128.2157.264.152.082.847.7
21 August 2009120.8151.561.350.076.944.5
24 August 2009121.6150.560.349.780.744.2
25 August 2009118.0147.359.349.479.344.0
26 August 2009119.5154.861.549.380.544.4
27 August 2009118.8153.460.449.678.943.5
28 August 2009118.1154.463.150.580.443.6
31 August 2009123.5159.063.651.881.945.0
1 September 2009130.5164.468.257.884.947.6
2 September 2009134.4166.971.460.387.549.3
3 September 2009142.8169.174.964.589.951.5
4 September 2009142.3168.575.063.189.749.7
7 September 2009146.3170.675.766.891.750.1
8 September 2009140.9170.171.265.388.749.3
9 September 2009132.3165.364.259.780.644.6
10 September 2009134.0163.762.955.981.042.7
11 September 2009130.2162.063.555.080.241.9
14 September 2009129.2164.362.257.880.342.6
15 September 2009123.9159.860.055.276.840.1
16 September 2009118.4154.857.953.872.538.4
17 September 2009117.1150.258.452.171.437.4
18 September 2009115.4146.756.452.569.938.1
21 September 2009117.9148.458.253.171.140.0
22 September 2009115.9145.056.750.770.639.3
23 September 2009116.4142.156.549.573.239.0
24 September 2009115.6142.956.048.973.338.5
25 September 2009121.1143.357.351.274.439.5
28 September 2009122.0144.257.752.675.540.6
29 September 2009123.1141.460.055.176.941.7
30 September 2009130.0145.463.158.879.544.4
1 October 2009138.0159.771.263.795.750.6
2 October 2009134.5163.870.164.093.850.0
5 October 2009130.4167.266.862.892.449.6
6 October 2009131.0161.463.862.290.449.2
7 October 2009131.8158.064.662.490.048.8
8 October 2009130.1155.764.561.288.748.7
9 October 2009126.1153.962.359.185.847.6
12 October 2009127.1154.162.859.687.147.6
13 October 2009131.5157.065.763.491.451.0
14 October 2009130.5156.063.161.590.148.8
15 October 2009132.4154.062.460.590.547.7
16 October 2009136.9153.460.358.688.446.0
19 October 2009135.3153.659.456.685.743.8
20 October 2009134.6151.358.856.885.542.8
21 October 2009131.2146.353.253.783.838.9
22 October 2009131.3146.953.252.983.837.9
23 October 2009134.2147.254.552.584.236.8
26 October 2009133.5144.954.151.382.736.0
27 October 2009136.9145.655.253.182.737.6
28 October 2009136.3145.954.252.982.437.1
29 October 2009138.2145.354.654.682.339.0
30 October 2009142.3146.856.255.784.340.2
2 November 2009139.5147.153.154.782.639.7
3 November 2009139.1145.551.755.382.039.3
4 November 2009138.2143.949.853.879.337.7
5 November 2009137.6140.949.053.577.637.3
6 November 2009138.2140.349.953.176.836.9
9 November 2009137.5140.149.653.276.836.8
10 November 2009138.7142.849.553.076.236.6
11 November 2009132.2136.742.146.469.430.7
12 November 2009132.0136.242.046.469.030.4
13 November 2009140.0139.943.649.271.732.5
16 November 2009153.9148.348.152.574.735.8
17 November 2009147.7139.847.650.374.033.7
18 November 2009156.0142.949.052.375.133.6
19 November 2009169.7149.253.055.378.936.4
20 November 2009172.3153.255.357.280.738.7
23 November 2009166.2149.854.056.678.838.1
24 November 2009173.6152.053.656.379.338.2
25 November 2009179.4155.354.555.679.537.4
26 November 2009201.6168.562.059.588.842.0
27 November 2009194.2170.662.360.887.142.5
30 November 2009183.6168.559.558.885.840.8
1 December 2009172.9164.457.558.183.540.6
2 December 2009168.7162.856.958.382.040.3
3 December 2009171.3160.956.057.381.140.3
4 December 2009176.5159.852.854.376.137.7
7 December 2009195.2163.558.055.976.738.6
8 December 2009221.0170.565.560.782.841.1
9 December 2009246.8189.777.469.587.545.4
10 December 2009227.0178.574.468.685.445.0
11 December 2009208.4165.968.862.681.941.6
14 December 2009228.8164.267.461.282.339.9
15 December 2009249.8162.467.861.179.940.0
16 December 2009231.8153.766.659.179.936.5
17 December 2009253.2158.771.764.682.538.3
18 December 2009265.9160.578.670.584.041.6
21 December 2009276.9159.181.573.784.441.4
22 December 2009248.3151.872.865.976.337.8
23 December 2009242.3147.769.563.372.735.3
24 December 2009241.7147.768.662.172.634.5
25 December 2009242.4148.269.462.673.134.9
28 December 2009238.0147.468.860.671.233.7
29 December 2009236.6146.267.558.773.529.4
30 December 2009238.7144.768.858.875.432.5
31 December 2009238.7145.268.259.175.532.2
1 January 2010238.7145.169.059.175.532.2
4 January 2010233.1138.067.357.971.732.1
5 January 2010227.9141.867.659.272.833.9
6 January 2010227.1151.269.162.273.935.3
7 January 2010227.3144.867.361.372.433.7
8 January 2010220.0140.261.257.069.331.0
11 January 2010217.5140.665.861.671.031.8
12 January 2010234.5144.269.463.574.233.2
13 January 2010257.7151.576.465.978.634.5
14 January 2010277.6157.488.669.880.659.9
15 January 2010273.4156.792.970.481.159.6
18 January 2010268.1156.994.372.581.259.4
19 January 2010264.3147.492.373.178.657.9
20 January 2010293.8161.3104.479.685.259.9
21 January 2010288.1156.7104.480.286.859.4
22 January 2010304.8159.5109.281.586.360.2
25 January 2010297.7149.798.074.082.954.9
26 January 2010303.7149.793.382.681.752.5
27 January 2010355.6155.8105.590.388.654.9
28 January 2010396.1165.4121.698.694.858.4
29 January 2010365.8165.1121.492.491.957.0
1 February 2010344.0162.1120.784.286.355.0
2 February 2010353.6160.8129.186.186.155.3
3 February 2010349.7162.7147.088.985.654.6
4 February 2010352.7166.4159.296.790.157.8
5 February 2010350.5174.4161.3100.194.460.3
8 February 2010362.5178.7162.799.995.059.9
9 February 2010324.4169.3147.490.990.155.3
10 February 2010282.8156.0135.279.082.452.3
11 February 2010273.2146.0118.476.080.849.6
12 February 2010296.1149.3123.979.686.352.5
15 February 2010304.9153.4123.482.386.055.2
16 February 2010320.4154.7125.081.085.555.3
17 February 2010318.4154.6118.480.285.254.5
18 February 2010329.3151.2117.577.881.752.3
19 February 2010317.5147.5112.175.180.849.7
22 February 2010315.6144.8110.072.682.049.7
23 February 2010332.0146.6111.774.486.251.7
24 February 2010338.9150.7114.675.688.853.6
25 February 2010355.1155.7117.479.693.656.6
26 February 2010326.1150.9111.476.089.555.8
1 March 2010316.0143.398.671.386.953.9
2 March 2010304.7140.994.473.885.351.8
3 March 2010285.8139.491.673.283.051.0
4 March 2010297.0139.593.575.183.652.5
5 March 2010291.1135.591.070.979.951.5
8 March 2010306.0133.789.368.478.950.2
9 March 2010313.2134.693.471.080.352.2
10 March 2010309.3129.688.168.878.051.0
11 March 2010314.8128.5106.069.377.949.7
12 March 2010305.9127.9106.869.979.150.1
15 March 2010305.5129.8110.471.979.750.1
16 March 2010299.9129.3111.171.779.549.5
17 March 2010299.7135.0114.773.680.551.1
18 March 2010313.7137.9116.275.881.951.1
19 March 2010323.9141.3120.677.684.551.7
22 March 2010337.3144.9125.878.486.452.3
23 March 2010324.9142.7123.976.885.450.9
24 March 2010328.2149.6125.975.484.149.9
25 March 2010312.8143.2123.871.778.447.0
26 March 2010305.2139.9114.468.577.246.9
29 March 2010316.1138.5114.269.578.646.3
30 March 2010333.1138.7116.070.978.745.7
31 March 2010343.7138.3112.772.488.944.9
1 April 2010345.5134.8108.771.786.444.8
2 April 2010345.7134.2108.171.386.044.9
5 April 2010345.2134.3107.971.685.845.1
6 April 2010383.9135.7110.273.687.046.0
7 April 2010405.0137.1116.275.688.546.2
8 April 2010426.8139.7127.876.489.145.2
9 April 2010398.5135.3119.971.583.340.7
12 April 2010349.5131.4116.766.780.938.7
13 April 2010366.5134.3120.470.483.439.9
14 April 2010394.0138.5129.272.084.841.5
15 April 2010400.6141.6126.371.684.140.5
16 April 2010430.3147.4139.474.886.541.8
19 April 2010453.5152.5151.876.587.241.7
20 April 2010478.3146.6154.876.586.440.8
21 April 2010501.4152.4169.379.189.543.5
22 April 2010578.7172.4190.688.894.749.9
23 April 2010559.5171.4191.092.094.849.4
26 April 2010651.5186.7218.2100.597.752.1
27 April 2010675.1216.9277.0112.5110.965.2
28 April 2010693.4224.7277.2108.2107.757.5
29 April 2010597.4210.6241.599.1100.751.1
30 April 2010594.5210.0212.2101.399.847.0
3 May 2010543.6204.8207.097.193.744.1
4 May 2010644.8233.8252.0115.6105.849.4
5 May 2010731.1270.4294.5131.7120.553.0
6 May 2010851.6300.2334.7162.9148.968.6
7 May 2010965.2305.9348.8164.2147.172.4
10 May 2010481.1176.8169.697.2101.447.0
11 May 2010450.6164.9158.999.0101.648.5
12 May 2010430.1163.1164.097.299.145.5
13 May 2010441.6163.7162.899.092.743.5
14 May 2010485.4174.2179.0108.4104.344.9
17 May 2010519.2183.5183.9112.4103.644.9
18 May 2010473.4179.3179.2116.9106.740.1
19 May 2010505.6182.2182.7125.8112.740.2
20 May 2010509.6196.3193.3138.6127.443.9
21 May 2010515.8200.5197.5138.6126.845.2
24 May 2010513.3201.0197.0140.5125.445.9
25 May 2010514.8215.3204.4155.7138.050.8
26 May 2010505.2216.6205.5155.2137.451.7
27 May 2010500.0214.2200.6152.4139.548.7
28 May 2010498.5214.6202.3153.0145.348.8
31 May 2010504.7214.7202.1159.8148.449.0
1 June 2010517.5223.0211.0165.2149.857.1
2 June 2010536.9229.2225.2176.7159.765.9
3 June 2010540.4233.1235.6184.2161.575.7
4 June 2010555.7252.5254.6194.4167.092.3
7 June 2010556.0258.6263.7203.8176.8102.3
8 June 2010560.7258.3271.6208.2178.1104.6
9 June 2010558.5253.5266.7200.4157.297.1
10 June 2010553.1248.8255.2186.5141.184.7
11 June 2010561.6254.3253.4189.6146.279.4
14 June 2010570.1263.6258.8204.2144.283.0
15 June 2010640.8281.0277.7206.4136.780.0
16 June 2010667.0289.3293.9221.1138.081.7
17 June 2010667.6290.0292.4211.1136.182.0
18 June 2010669.2281.1287.5186.3124.774.7
21 June 2010672.1269.6285.7169.8121.467.0
22 June 2010710.6271.7293.1182.5132.675.4
23 June 2010772.1281.0307.7189.3140.585.7
24 June 2010780.8285.8309.6185.0143.188.1
25 June 2010780.7291.0312.6185.3146.894.6
28 June 2010800.2295.5313.5195.1153.991.5
29 June 2010789.3295.1316.4205.0157.191.0
30 June 2010784.9292.3312.2198.4151.786.7
1 July 2010770.9290.5301.4200.9151.282.5
2 July 2010762.8273.7278.7194.0143.972.7
5 July 2010766.0272.7277.1206.6146.869.2
6 July 2010755.9269.2280.0208.3147.668.7
7 July 2010756.0269.7283.8205.7148.569.0
8 July 2010764.4262.6278.2201.8141.964.9
9 July 2010763.7261.9274.9205.9138.961.0
12 July 2010764.3267.0280.4207.3144.261.5
13 July 2010755.5266.3284.6200.5142.358.2
14 July 2010760.7282.3291.2207.2146.860.2
15 July 2010766.9284.6287.3197.1147.762.8
16 July 2010764.3282.6285.5185.6147.365.3
19 July 2010778.0283.9282.9175.7140.266.3
20 July 2010782.7276.6282.9169.1136.567.3
21 July 2010785.8275.8281.8167.9137.468.1
22 July 2010774.1276.9287.4169.6135.769.1
23 July 2010767.4271.5284.3164.9131.865.5
26 July 2010761.0259.1274.3148.2123.561.2
27 July 2010749.9238.8242.9137.4120.455.6
28 July 2010747.3223.0233.3147.6123.357.3
29 July 2010750.3232.4238.7152.1125.659.2
30 July 2010762.8236.1252.4154.2128.563.2
2 August 2010749.2227.5246.3146.2122.262.2
3 August 2010748.1230.2250.1152.0126.663.3
4 August 2010762.4229.3251.2154.0125.361.0
5 August 2010763.4239.2251.4155.2127.159.2
6 August 2010762.8236.7249.2152.5126.556.6
9 August 2010764.4250.0247.5150.7125.354.6
10 August 2010777.9267.0254.2164.3131.757.8
11 August 2010793.2289.7272.7167.9137.960.7
12 August 2010797.4287.6271.9175.9141.861.1
13 August 2010809.0293.1283.7185.8147.965.7
16 August 2010836.5299.2287.3186.7152.368.1
17 August 2010832.6291.8281.2174.0146.266.4
18 August 2010824.2288.3278.0168.0140.463.0
19 August 2010833.5293.1286.7173.3146.064.3
20 August 2010848.1303.3294.4178.9151.468.2
23 August 2010862.1305.1297.1178.0149.166.2
24 August 2010885.0318.1306.6184.0157.268.0
25 August 2010926.1343.6324.0184.4161.170.1
26 August 2010925.8345.5325.8185.8161.070.0
27 August 2010924.6352.0329.5185.8157.570.0
30 August 2010927.1352.6331.8192.6165.969.7
31 August 2010923.2356.4333.0193.2171.071.5
1 September 2010910.2347.5326.0180.9157.568.6
2 September 2010900.9342.3324.6172.7151.964.6
3 September 2010896.8340.3324.8167.1145.463.7
6 September 2010914.3342.6333.4174.1147.868.8
7 September 2010941.9372.8354.0180.6154.274.1
8 September 2010951.9371.2350.7174.1149.570.9
9 September 2010936.7354.0342.1172.0145.470.2
10 September 2010933.2341.3337.3171.4143.772.9
13 September 2010894.4339.1330.4172.6145.474.0
14 September 2010899.9348.6334.4178.6150.080.0
15 September 2010907.8350.1336.6175.7147.880.3
16 September 2010907.2355.9348.0172.5143.481.7
17 September 2010913.3386.6365.8177.3150.686.0
20 September 2010909.3401.5392.7176.2151.388.1
21 September 2010884.1383.2385.1175.0148.182.8
22 September 2010869.0394.4379.4178.5153.582.4
23 September 2010874.9418.4401.7183.7161.288.9
24 September 2010870.5412.8404.9180.6158.390.2
27 September 2010862.9429.9414.8186.8163.785.6
28 September 2010856.1449.3426.6193.4169.188.4
29 September 2010840.5446.0423.3195.7169.789.1
30 September 2010817.4429.5402.5184.5160.185.8
1 October 2010786.0402.3384.1180.7157.681.5
4 October 2010776.7402.4382.7179.9157.387.3
5 October 2010773.8410.3393.0178.0154.286.9
6 October 2010765.8422.0400.6177.6153.888.6
7 October 2010755.2422.8401.5176.8152.790.4
8 October 2010751.7421.6398.1173.7149.088.7
11 October 2010699.7417.6389.6171.0145.785.2
12 October 2010678.7421.9398.1175.0148.785.9
13 October 2010650.2413.9390.3174.5146.987.2
14 October 2010659.1387.4376.0170.1144.985.8
15 October 2010652.3374.9336.9161.7138.882.5
18 October 2010649.4361.6314.4161.6137.783.2
19 October 2010660.1383.2318.5163.1138.184.7
20 October 2010660.9387.5329.2161.8135.787.5
21 October 2010681.2403.0338.0166.9137.987.1
22 October 2010688.3404.7338.8166.1137.787.4
25 October 2010691.0398.8323.7161.6134.683.8
26 October 2010715.9392.9312.9156.7131.678.3
27 October 2010782.6420.6329.1161.2136.780.7
28 October 2010784.1424.4337.5162.7136.980.1
29 October 2010804.3440.0343.4169.3142.480.4
1 November 2010822.3461.9362.1176.3145.581.3
2 November 2010832.0482.6376.9181.9149.284.4
3 November 2010843.6502.6387.9187.0152.484.0
4 November 2010881.6526.0421.1194.4156.686.8
5 November 2010904.1520.6409.8194.7155.988.5
8 November 2010901.7546.9438.6201.6164.493.9
9 November 2010891.1553.2435.6198.6162.692.8
10 November 2010911.0619.5459.5206.0166.194.8
11 November 2010916.0646.1460.0220.0179.798.7
12 November 2010887.7562.9423.2201.9164.692.2
15 November 2010885.7540.0417.6195.8158.687.8
16 November 2010899.7562.0414.3198.5160.289.2
17 November 2010903.3554.4410.6202.0161.288.9
18 November 2010889.5541.4405.6201.3159.489.5
19 November 2010886.1541.5404.4201.9154.888.1
22 November 2010918.3544.1407.1208.8156.189.8
23 November 2010932.9586.3435.4234.5171.497.9
24 November 2010921.0615.3430.5235.3163.289.9
25 November 2010922.2632.9431.1246.3168.294.4
26 November 2010903.9646.2425.3244.4168.394.4
29 November 2010902.8649.3427.6267.0188.1112.2
30 November 2010918.7668.5430.4283.3199.7132.7
1 December 2010902.9616.3386.5250.9173.0119.5
2 December 2010883.3568.2332.2225.9158.3109.7
3 December 2010870.6528.9307.4219.4157.6105.5
6 December 2010877.0531.6309.2230.4164.7110.4
7 December 2010871.1507.8303.3225.6157.1107.1
8 December 2010867.6501.7306.5222.0153.498.9
9 December 2010874.1503.3313.8234.0159.299.1
10 December 2010872.9513.0330.2245.2160.3101.2
13 December 2010870.6514.3332.7247.6161.099.9
14 December 2010871.4521.8335.2248.8159.0101.7
15 December 2010882.9519.1339.6242.2153.0100.5
16 December 2010885.6521.4339.0245.1156.091.9
17 December 2010887.4540.3342.9248.9161.395.6
20 December 2010893.4565.3349.3252.8165.799.3
21 December 2010897.9589.7353.9252.9167.195.9
22 December 2010906.2601.3361.1251.8171.499.6
23 December 2010922.7602.4363.7248.8171.8102.0
24 December 2010920.4602.6364.5248.9171.4101.4
27 December 2010925.2602.1363.6243.1168.8101.3
28 December 2010931.3606.2362.4249.8177.6102.3
29 December 2010947.1606.6362.9243.5182.2100.7
30 December 2010952.5608.8364.9249.1186.2100.5
31 December 2010950.9609.5363.8249.0185.2100.7
3 January 2011959.9609.3369.8248.9181.0102.6
4 January 2011970.0609.6372.6242.6173.9100.2
5 January 2011967.9607.6371.2237.1170.7100.2
6 January 2011972.5612.9404.4254.7185.4115.2
7 January 2011973.6620.1423.5263.8192.8125.9
10 January 2011942.3604.0410.9267.5197.6135.0
11 January 2011875.8566.4397.5255.9187.3134.5
12 January 2011817.3530.9373.7240.2173.5111.7
13 January 2011811.4525.2370.5230.5166.1100.3
14 January 2011808.1548.9378.8230.4162.7104.1
17 January 2011801.2553.4378.0239.5168.2108.2
18 January 2011832.9576.8395.5236.3166.9108.9
19 January 2011838.7581.6395.6227.1162.3115.3
20 January 2011820.8565.1366.9218.1161.6111.6
21 January 2011812.7561.6370.7202.6153.5102.7
24 January 2011807.2572.9378.4208.7152.3104.0
25 January 2011819.6570.4391.0220.0159.5106.7
26 January 2011826.9575.7394.5225.1161.2110.0
27 January 2011829.7591.4390.2229.4161.7112.9
28 January 2011831.2601.0392.4231.0163.2114.2
31 January 2011818.3599.7389.3221.3156.8111.4
1 February 2011782.7580.4371.1199.1142.4100.0
2 February 2011754.5556.4364.2183.8127.788.8
3 February 2011767.3564.7377.3197.3140.794.4
4 February 2011768.4562.1379.4189.2134.790.0
7 February 2011779.9564.5391.2199.6143.894.7
8 February 2011794.1566.6398.1205.8149.897.3
9 February 2011795.5569.3405.5201.0145.493.7
10 February 2011810.9578.1399.5202.9146.895.2
11 February 2011822.2579.8401.8208.4148.699.3
14 February 2011828.8585.2412.6215.9153.1100.9
15 February 2011852.1594.8412.8213.4151.899.3
16 February 2011862.2594.5416.3210.0149.499.3
17 February 2011861.2597.2427.0218.0155.6102.7
18 February 2011846.7594.1424.3212.1154.198.7
21 February 2011852.8595.8426.7217.6161.4103.8
22 February 2011861.7593.5430.6221.6166.6105.4
23 February 2011861.4600.9432.5221.8168.7108.9
24 February 2011873.0618.6437.2224.1170.8111.6
25 February 2011872.8619.6439.3225.3170.1113.3
28 February 2011876.8617.1433.9222.0167.2109.9
1 March 2011886.3613.4427.1218.0163.9107.6
2 March 2011888.3618.9426.8213.0160.7106.1
3 March 2011875.7608.2419.6207.8158.1101.4
4 March 2011897.6611.1420.2211.5161.2101.3
7 March 2011905.8614.3428.5210.8162.0100.6
8 March 2011953.5626.7432.1217.2165.2104.2
9 March 2011961.0626.0433.9222.1170.0108.9
10 March 2011950.6625.1424.8225.9172.2108.9
11 March 2011960.0643.4438.7221.3165.2103.0
14 March 2011920.7626.3421.3204.3155.891.8
15 March 2011934.4635.5427.4205.8156.892.7
16 March 2011923.6642.7441.4208.4160.090.0
17 March 2011912.0644.5439.7207.2156.189.8
18 March 2011910.0632.9418.2197.8149.588.3
21 March 2011902.5636.7413.4191.6148.889.9
22 March 2011925.7657.7423.7193.3151.395.1
23 March 2011931.5681.3439.5193.7153.396.9
24 March 2011932.6675.5441.6192.4151.295.8
25 March 2011929.6683.9450.6189.3147.893.2
28 March 2011933.8676.9463.5188.7148.293.9
29 March 2011937.1678.3466.2187.4146.191.8
30 March 2011942.4676.3476.2186.8144.292.2
31 March 2011948.3686.9505.4194.3146.894.8
1 April 2011937.5660.6514.2194.2143.192.3
4 April 2011934.9644.1522.2191.2138.787.6
5 April 2011929.2629.1537.5190.3136.787.4
6 April 2011928.4593.7510.7180.1131.381.6
7 April 2011939.5584.1517.7182.0132.281.8
8 April 2011937.8575.9518.2178.1126.881.8
11 April 2011936.8566.5513.3175.0122.178.7
12 April 2011943.1564.4519.4175.0122.178.7
13 April 2011948.4565.2530.8179.7125.580.9
14 April 2011984.6590.9545.4189.4128.984.7
15 April 20111044.8633.1561.9203.9135.493.4
18 April 20111130.1650.9583.3230.6153.1107.9
19 April 20111120.5652.6581.2223.2148.1103.7
20 April 20111144.6676.0597.5216.6143.6101.0
21 April 20111164.3722.1624.1221.2149.7103.8
22 April 20111164.3722.0624.1221.2149.7103.8
25 April 20111164.3722.0624.1221.2149.7103.8
26 April 20111207.9720.8635.3225.7156.0107.6
27 April 20111289.2716.4632.9219.7152.2104.0
28 April 20111244.1717.4639.7212.6150.5100.2
29 April 20111242.3733.4640.4205.3149.399.4
2 May 20111240.9722.6638.5203.5146.498.1
3 May 20111199.2709.9629.7198.1141.898.0
4 May 20111211.8689.5622.5196.2140.798.3
5 May 20111229.4705.7647.7202.2146.3101.8
6 May 20111233.6718.1638.7207.0149.2102.0
9 May 20111260.9754.0656.9222.0156.9109.6
10 May 20111231.0745.3659.0215.4151.6108.0
11 May 20111244.1749.2629.5212.7150.3107.2
12 May 20111241.7740.4615.2210.7147.3108.4
13 May 20111236.4743.3613.8218.2153.0109.8
16 May 20111249.7729.4585.5213.3147.0106.8
17 May 20111253.2731.1591.3221.9151.4108.1
18 May 20111268.0722.9606.7223.9151.0108.9
19 May 20111288.4733.1599.8228.1164.6109.1
20 May 20111351.5748.1632.9242.5171.6116.7
23 May 20111401.6784.3663.6249.9179.2120.6
24 May 20111368.8785.9669.0240.1171.5113.7
25 May 20111367.7794.3668.2230.7168.1113.4
26 May 20111338.3804.3662.5230.6171.6113.4
27 May 20111343.3810.0660.1233.7176.4116.7
30 May 20111345.5809.5677.9241.0183.0120.9
31 May 20111301.8801.6659.0234.4176.1115.5
1 June 20111316.7798.9674.2233.4174.3112.0
2 June 20111326.4801.6666.4230.4170.1107.5
3 June 20111287.9774.8674.7217.1157.199.6
6 June 20111282.4764.5670.4224.1163.7107.4
7 June 20111279.5768.0684.4223.6164.0105.9
8 June 20111308.8781.9706.1231.9170.6110.7
9 June 20111362.9805.2725.9241.0177.8113.8
10 June 20111376.4827.7747.3251.1183.3116.0
13 June 20111401.6839.1771.0253.4183.6116.9
14 June 20111436.5836.7774.0245.3175.3112.0
15 June 20111477.3859.7772.7259.5188.2117.6
16 June 20111503.1863.7795.4274.2193.2122.1
17 June 20111398.0842.8794.8261.4185.8115.8
20 June 20111437.7849.2818.5262.3188.7117.2
21 June 20111427.7845.0814.1252.7185.6116.5

* Relative to Germany.  Return to text

Top-right panel
Projected Debt-to-GDP*

Percent
Period Greece Ireland Portugal Spain Italy
2009127667553116
2010143979262117
20111531069867117
201216511210369116
201316911610571114
201416811510471112
201516611510371111
201617011410370109
201717311410269108
201817711310268106
201918111310167105
202018611210166103

* Assumes Greece, Ireland, and Portugal are able to access market financing on the timeline set out in their respective IMF programs.  Return to text

Middle-left panel
Direct Credit Exposure of Banking Sector, December 2010

Greece Greece,
Ireland, &
Portugal
Spain Core
European
Banks*
$bil. % Tier 1 $bil. % Tier 1 $bil. % Tier 1 $bil. % Tier 1
United States7164747556064
Western Europe13467053163028----

* Core Europe defined as Belgium, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.  Return to table

Source: U.S. Country Exposure Report, BIS, and ECB. Corrected for break in series and excluding exposure from derivatives contracts.

Middle-right panel
U.S. Direct Credit Exposure to Periphery

Billions of dollars
Period Greece Greece, Ireland,
Portugal, and Spain
March 201014141
December 20107111

Bottom-left panel
Euro-Dollar Exchange Rate

Date Euros per dollar
(March 1, 2011 = 100)
1 March 2011100.00
2 March 201199.60
3 March 201199.04
4 March 201198.78
7 March 201198.83
8 March 201199.29
9 March 201199.33
10 March 201199.93
11 March 201199.63
14 March 201198.84
15 March 201198.89
16 March 201199.22
17 March 201198.52
18 March 201197.68
21 March 201197.38
22 March 201197.19
23 March 201197.80
24 March 201197.27
25 March 201197.66
28 March 201197.94
29 March 201198.03
30 March 201198.00
31 March 201197.39
1 April 201197.17
4 April 201197.13
5 April 201197.07
6 April 201196.37
7 April 201196.68
8 April 201195.68
11 April 201195.57
12 April 201195.56
13 April 201195.41
14 April 201195.50
15 April 201195.64
18 April 201197.20
19 April 201196.47
20 April 201195.18
21 April 201194.71
22 April 201194.97
25 April 201194.77
26 April 201194.45
27 April 201194.23
28 April 201193.43
29 April 201193.20
2 May 201192.89
3 May 201192.86
4 May 201192.96
5 May 201194.72
6 May 201195.29
9 May 201196.59
10 May 201196.20
11 May 201196.80
12 May 201197.08
13 May 201197.68
16 May 201197.14
17 May 201197.58
18 May 201196.80
19 May 201196.91
20 May 201197.47
23 May 201198.56
24 May 201197.92
25 May 201197.95
26 May 201198.05
27 May 201196.68
30 May 2011ND
31 May 201196.08
1 June 201195.72
2 June 201195.75
3 June 201194.58
6 June 201194.48
7 June 201194.13
8 June 201194.69
9 June 201195.04
10 June 201196.16
13 June 201196.14
14 June 201195.44
15 June 201197.13
16 June 201197.58
17 June 201196.42
20 June 201196.46

Bottom-right panel
Euro-area Stock Prices

March 1, 2011 = 100
Date DJ Euro Stoxx DJ Euro Stoxx Banks
1 March 2011100.00100.00
2 March 201199.2599.13
3 March 201199.6098.36
4 March 201199.0097.15
7 March 201198.6495.91
8 March 201199.0396.66
9 March 201198.8996.25
10 March 201197.9195.26
11 March 201196.9995.25
14 March 201196.0697.06
15 March 201193.8395.16
16 March 201192.0192.29
17 March 201193.9294.10
18 March 201194.2694.26
21 March 201196.3296.59
22 March 201195.9996.37
23 March 201196.4696.26
24 March 201197.8997.73
25 March 201197.9597.27
28 March 201198.0897.46
29 March 201198.0395.78
30 March 201198.9095.53
31 March 201198.1192.96
1 April 201199.6594.92
4 April 201199.6793.92
5 April 201199.5693.29
6 April 2011100.1395.55
7 April 201199.7196.65
8 April 2011100.2097.06
11 April 201199.8496.57
12 April 201198.4495.37
13 April 201199.1395.47
14 April 201198.1993.30
15 April 201198.2692.31
18 April 201196.1189.27
19 April 201196.5489.40
20 April 201198.5289.66
21 April 201198.9391.05
22 April 2011NDND
25 April 2011NDND
26 April 201199.5591.41
27 April 2011100.1792.52
28 April 2011100.9294.06
29 April 2011101.1694.39
2 May 2011101.2493.97
3 May 2011100.8393.62
4 May 201199.3392.76
5 May 201198.7391.43
6 May 201199.7192.27
9 May 201198.5589.92
10 May 201199.6791.59
11 May 201199.8291.68
12 May 201199.0591.07
13 May 201198.5690.12
16 May 201198.1689.76
17 May 201196.9989.17
18 May 201197.4689.52
19 May 201198.2389.99
20 May 201197.2788.14
23 May 201195.2785.95
24 May 201195.5785.85
25 May 201196.0187.77
26 May 201195.5287.06
27 May 201196.1588.09
30 May 201196.0687.35
31 May 201197.5089.38
1 June 201196.5187.82
2 June 201195.1386.79
3 June 201195.3288.49
6 June 201194.7086.65
7 June 201194.8386.80
8 June 201193.8785.51
9 June 201194.7885.57
10 June 201193.3184.24
13 June 201193.3484.07
14 June 201194.6985.87
15 June 201193.2883.52
16 June 201192.9183.21
17 June 201193.8786.01
20 June 201193.1284.99
21 June 201194.2486.50

Exhibit 6
Global Outlook

Top-left panel
Real GDP*

Percent change, annual rate
2011 2012p
Q1 Q2p H2p
1.Total Foreign GDP4.12.83.63.5
April Tealbook3.73.03.53.6
2.Advanced Foreign Economies2.31.42.42.3
3.Euro area3.41.61.41.8
4.Japan-3.5-3.84.42.8
5.Emerging Market Economies6.24.45.14.9
6.China8.78.18.58.3
7.Emerging Asia8.85.45.95.9
8.Mexico2.12.94.63.8

* GDP aggregates weighted by U.S. goods exports.  Return to text

Top-right panel
First-Quarter Real GDP

Percent change, a.r.
April Tealbook June Tealbook
AFE ex. Japan2.803.06
Emerging Asia5.928.81
South America4.676.99
Japan-0.10-3.48

Middle-left panel
Foreign Mfg. PMI ex. Japan

Period Diffusion index
January 200853.66
February 200853.57
March 200853.02
April 200852.21
May 200851.87
June 200850.07
July 200849.25
August 200848.31
September 200846.12
October 200842.94
November 200837.59
December 200836.09
January 200937.97
February 200939.92
March 200942.05
April 200945.52
May 200948.12
June 200949.47
July 200951.54
August 200953.41
September 200953.25
October 200953.72
November 200954.60
December 200954.93
January 201056.07
February 201056.07
March 201056.38
April 201057.00
May 201055.22
June 201053.93
July 201053.41
August 201053.02
September 201052.22
October 201054.02
November 201054.60
December 201055.69
January 201156.14
February 201156.00
March 201154.70
April 201154.16
May 201153.04

Middle-center panel
China

12-month percent change
Period Retail sales Outstanding bank loans
January 200821.2216.74
February 200819.1215.73
March 200821.5014.78
April 200822.0214.72
May 200821.6014.86
June 200823.0014.12
July 200823.3014.58
August 200823.2014.29
September 200823.1914.48
October 200822.0214.58
November 200820.8013.22
December 200819.0015.94
January 200918.5018.62
February 200911.6021.48
March 200914.7027.11
April 200914.7527.10
May 200915.2228.02
June 200915.0331.88
July 200915.1631.42
August 200915.3731.60
September 200915.5231.68
October 200916.2131.73
November 200915.8133.86
December 200917.5431.74
January 201018.2429.31
February 201032.2927.23
March 201021.5121.81
April 201023.2021.96
May 201024.2021.50
June 201024.0218.17
July 201023.3118.43
August 201024.2618.58
September 201024.0418.55
October 201021.9119.28
November 201022.6819.83
December 201021.5719.89
January 201119.9016.88
February 201111.6316.21
March 201120.0216.19
April 201118.5815.83
May 201118.0015.38

Middle-right panel
Japan

Period Suppliers' delivery times
(Diffusion index)
Real consumption
(January 2008 = 100)
January 200846.39100.00
February 200847.16101.95
March 200845.41100.10
April 200847.8999.49
May 200849.0999.75
June 200847.9899.87
July 200847.7199.96
August 200849.5199.13
September 200849.1499.33
October 200850.9099.30
November 200852.6497.98
December 200853.9597.44
January 200955.6996.47
February 200956.1595.41
March 200953.0996.66
April 200952.3597.27
May 200950.3997.39
June 200950.2497.76
July 200949.2697.44
August 200949.5197.55
September 200945.4398.07
October 200947.1198.38
November 200946.2398.09
December 200945.7499.12
January 201047.4599.21
February 201044.5799.00
March 201043.58101.37
April 201044.55100.34
May 201043.1499.23
June 201045.0199.70
July 201044.09100.48
August 201045.78101.13
September 201047.59100.60
October 201050.1898.75
November 201049.31100.46
December 201048.9799.74
January 201148.5599.93
February 201147.16100.95
March 201131.3695.98
April 201123.1498.34
May 201141.50ND

Bottom-left panel
Headline Consumer Prices*

Four-quarter percent change
Period Emerging Asia Latin America Advanced foreign
economies
2008:Q16.654.412.26
2008:Q27.145.462.73
2008:Q35.976.103.48
2008:Q43.596.651.99
2009:Q11.016.351.00
2009:Q2-0.265.910.03
2009:Q3-0.384.97-0.77
2009:Q41.283.910.25
2010:Q12.804.641.06
2010:Q23.254.091.23
2010:Q33.533.881.38
2010:Q44.334.451.81
2011:Q14.803.812.15
Forecast
2011:Q25.013.712.61
2011:Q34.883.932.64
2011:Q43.783.712.12
2012:Q13.123.631.63
2012:Q22.933.951.36
2012:Q32.864.001.39
2012:Q42.833.951.41

* Inflation aggregates weighted by U.S. non-oil goods imports.  Return to text

Bottom-right panel
Implied Forward OIS Rates*

Percent
Period April 20 June 21
Euro area United Kingdom Euro Area United Kingdom
April 20111.090.52NDND
May 20111.140.53NDND
June 20111.200.551.190.51
July 20111.310.571.250.51
August 20111.410.601.340.50
September 20111.490.641.400.51
October 20111.560.681.440.51
November 20111.620.721.450.51
December 20111.690.761.470.52
January 20121.750.791.490.52
February 20121.790.861.510.53
March 20121.930.981.520.56
April 20121.951.021.530.60
May 20121.961.061.530.67
June 20121.981.101.540.64
July 20122.011.161.550.61
August 20122.051.221.550.58
September 20122.081.291.560.61
October 20122.141.371.560.64
November 20122.191.451.570.68
December 20122.251.531.590.75

* OIS rates less one basis point per month term premium adjustment.  Return to text


Exhibit 7
Outlook for U.S. External Sector

Top-left panel
Trade in Real Goods and Services

Percent change, a.r.
Period Exports Imports
2010:Q111.3711.21
2010:Q29.1233.46
2010:Q36.7616.81
2010:Q48.60-12.59
2011:Q17.845.46
Forecast
2011:Q210.362.63
2011:Q310.3110.64
2011:Q49.661.26
2012:Q19.511.70
2012:Q29.033.62
2012:Q38.745.74
2012:Q48.634.90

Top-right panel
Broad Real Dollar

2008:Q1 = 100
Period Broad Real Dollar April TB
2008:Q1100.00ND
2008:Q298.29ND
2008:Q3100.81ND
2008:Q4109.15ND
2009:Q1111.47ND
2009:Q2107.49ND
2009:Q3104.50ND
2009:Q4101.81ND
2010:Q1102.54ND
2010:Q2103.46ND
2010:Q3102.02ND
2010:Q498.24ND
2011:Q196.9296.95
Forecast
2011:Q294.6895.05
2011:Q394.1394.39
2011:Q493.5793.74
2012:Q192.9693.02
2012:Q292.2892.24
2012:Q391.6091.45
2012:Q490.9190.67

Middle-left panel
Contribution to U.S. Real GDP Growth

Period Percentage points, a.r.
2010-0.56
2011:Q10.10
Forecast
2011:Q20.89
2011:H20.37
20120.59

[Data are approximate.]

Bottom-left panel
U.S. Core Import Prices

Period Percent change, a.r.
2008:Q18.35
2008:Q211.44
2008:Q34.99
2008:Q4-9.41
2009:Q1-10.00
2009:Q2-2.36
2009:Q31.15
2009:Q44.32
2010:Q14.22
2010:Q23.06
2010:Q3-0.82
2010:Q44.31
2011:Q18.08
Forecast
2011:Q27.19
2011:Q33.50
2011:Q41.54
2012:Q11.38
2012:Q21.46
2012:Q31.49
2012:Q41.47
Contributions from:
Percent change, a.r.
Period Exchange rates
and foreign prices
Non-fuel primary
commodity prices
2008:H13.961.65
2008:H2-0.03-2.20
2009:H1-2.65-2.90
2009:H22.961.81
2010:H11.312.59
2010:H21.631.84
Forecast
2011:H13.762.68
2011:H21.770.51
2012:H11.42-0.01
2012:H21.460.00

Bottom-right panel
Commodity Price Outlook

Period WTI crude oil (Dollars per barrel) Nonfuel (Index, 2008:Q1 = 100)
Current April Tealbook Current April Tealbook
2008:Q197.95ND100.00ND
2008:Q2123.96ND103.21ND
2008:Q3118.01ND98.04ND
2008:Q458.32ND72.68ND
2009:Q142.96ND68.62ND
2009:Q259.55ND73.98ND
2009:Q368.20ND82.75ND
2009:Q476.06ND88.73ND
2010:Q178.69ND96.08ND
2010:Q277.89ND99.88ND
2010:Q376.13ND100.57ND
2010:Q485.08ND114.17ND
2011:Q194.1394.13127.91127.98
2011:Q2103.20107.61126.98130.46
Forecast
2011:Q397.83108.37125.29130.31
2011:Q499.20108.66125.47130.20
2012:Q1100.09108.40125.84130.23
2012:Q2100.81107.67125.99130.20
2012:Q3101.23106.65125.89129.91
2012:Q4101.41105.82125.71129.53

Exhibit 8
Forecasting Commodity Prices

Top-left panel
WTI Crude Oil Futures*

Dollars per barrel
Futures in 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
200327.9625.0323.9823.7423.7623.7823.8023.86ND ND ND ND ND
2004ND 34.3831.8629.6128.6628.3127.9527.7527.96ND ND ND ND
2005ND ND 53.7155.9753.4751.4049.9849.0348.2847.93ND ND ND
2006ND ND ND 68.7471.9271.0769.5268.4567.4766.6265.97ND ND
2007ND ND ND ND 61.8969.7270.9470.1268.9768.2567.8566.60ND
2008NDNDNDNDND111.76107.39102.96101.15100.43100.23100.28100.55

* Each line represents futures prices in April of the indicated year.  Return to text

Source: Bloomberg.

Top-right panel
Why Flat Futures Curves?

  • Market participants can arbitrage between spot and futures prices through inventories.
  • Costs and benefits of holding inventories create a wedge between spot and futures prices.
  • When these costs and benefits are not large, futures will be flat.

Middle-left panel
EME Asia IP Consensus Forecasts

Percent change over previous year
Forecast in 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
20036.986.656.876.756.726.836.59NDNDNDNDND
2004ND9.388.038.168.608.838.358.42NDNDNDND
2005NDND8.918.259.049.248.598.498.20NDNDND
2006NDNDND11.2910.6310.6510.7610.4410.399.83NDND
2007NDNDNDND10.9310.7810.5310.5210.5110.039.94ND
2008NDNDNDNDND11.5911.1610.8210.4510.3110.069.64

Source: Consensus Economics, April issues.

Middle-right panel
New Forecasting Approach

  • Adjust futures to account for market surprises for global growth and the dollar.
  • Predict surprises as difference between staff forecast and private forecasts.
  • Map surprises into prices based on historical relationships.

Past Forecasts Under Both Methods

Bottom-left panel
WTI Crude Oil
Dollars per barrel
Period Actual historical December 2003 futures forecast March 2007 futures forecast March 2007 proposed forecast March 2009 futures forecast March 2009 proposed forecast January 2010 futures forecast January 2010 proposed forecast Current futures forecast Current proposed forecast
2002:Q121.61NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q226.27NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q328.33NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q428.18NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q134.12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q229.04NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q330.22NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q431.1831.18NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q135.2529.44NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q238.3428.31NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q343.8927.26NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q448.3126.47NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q149.6825.91NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q253.0925.54NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q363.0825.27NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q460.0325.12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q163.36NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q270.54NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q370.44NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q460.07NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q157.99ND57.9957.99NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q264.97ND60.5559.70NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q375.48ND63.3562.01NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q490.75ND64.6062.79NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q197.95ND65.3763.09NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q2123.96ND65.8463.09NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q3118.01ND66.1462.93NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q458.32ND66.3162.65NDNDNDNDNDND
2009:Q142.96NDNDND42.9642.96NDNDNDND
2009:Q259.55NDNDND43.8735.81NDNDNDND
2009:Q368.20NDNDND47.2334.84NDNDNDND
2009:Q476.06NDNDND49.0732.70NDNDNDND
2010:Q178.69NDNDND50.6130.47NDNDNDND
2010:Q277.89NDNDND52.1028.3478.6978.69NDND
2010:Q376.13NDNDND53.5526.3280.3982.55NDND
2010:Q485.08NDNDND55.0224.4382.0485.37NDND
2011:Q194.13NDNDNDNDND83.5788.12NDND
2011:Q2103.20NDNDNDNDND84.7490.55103.20103.20
2011:Q3NDNDNDNDNDND85.5692.6597.8397.95
2011:Q4NDNDNDNDNDND86.1994.5899.2099.45
2012:Q1NDNDNDNDNDND86.8896.61100.09100.47
2012:Q2NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND100.81101.31
2012:Q3NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND101.23101.87
2012:Q4NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND101.41102.18

Source: USIT model.

Bottom-right panel
Non-fuel Commodity Prices
2005 = 100
Period Actual historical December 2003 futures forecast December 2003 proposed forecast March 2007 futures forecast March 2007 proposed forecast March 2009 futures forecast March 2009 proposed forecast January 2010 futures forecast January 2010 proposed forecast Current futures forecast Current proposed forecast
2002:Q171.69NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q274.56NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q378.20NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2002:Q479.13NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q179.37NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q277.66NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q378.8078.8078.80NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2003:Q484.8783.5786.12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q192.3985.2088.59NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q293.4585.7489.98NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q392.3585.0690.07NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2004:Q491.9384.0789.84NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q198.3484.3090.90NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q298.9384.2891.71NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q399.7584.0192.26NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2005:Q4102.9883.8092.86NDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q1112.80NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q2127.46NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q3130.70NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2006:Q4135.12NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q1138.83NDND138.83138.83NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q2149.33NDND142.05141.35NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q3143.66NDND142.99141.58NDNDNDNDNDND
2007:Q4143.44NDND143.04140.93NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q1159.39NDND142.86140.06NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q2164.50NDND142.16138.69NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q3156.27NDND141.50137.35NDNDNDNDNDND
2008:Q4115.84NDND140.87136.07NDNDNDNDNDND
2009:Q1109.37NDNDNDND109.37109.37NDNDNDND
2009:Q2117.92NDNDNDND105.6698.37NDNDNDND
2009:Q3131.89NDNDNDND106.3092.14NDNDNDND
2009:Q4141.43NDNDNDND107.0586.39141.43141.43NDND
2010:Q1153.15NDNDNDND107.9681.11149.31151.02NDND
2010:Q2159.19NDNDNDND108.6876.02149.97153.42NDND
2010:Q3160.31NDNDNDND109.2071.11150.30155.52NDND
2010:Q4181.97NDNDNDND109.6566.48150.38157.39NDND
2011:Q1203.87NDNDNDNDNDND150.86159.70NDND
2011:Q2202.39NDNDNDNDNDND151.16161.85202.39202.39
2011:Q3NDNDNDNDNDNDND151.39163.95199.70200.15
2011:Q4NDNDNDNDNDNDND151.64166.10199.99200.90
2012:Q1NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND200.57201.93
2012:Q2NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND200.82202.63
2012:Q3NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND200.66202.93
2012:Q4NDNDNDNDNDNDNDNDND200.36203.09

Source: USIT model.


Exhibit 9
Forecasting Commodity Prices (Continued)

Top-left panel
Features of New Approach

  • No improvement in forecasting accuracy.
  • Improves consistency with Tealbook forecast.
  • Provides simple framework for characterizing risks.

Top-right panel
Forecasting Performance, One Year Ahead*

Root Mean Squared Errors
Oil Non-fuel
Random walk4122
Futures forecast4021
Proposed forecast4323

* From August 2002 to January 2010.  Return to text

Alternative Scenarios for Oil Prices

Middle-left panel
World GDP Growth
Dollars per barrel
Period June Tealbook Proposed forecast World growth ½
percentage point
faster
World growth ½
percentage point
slower
2010:Q178.69NDNDND
2010:Q277.89NDNDND
2010:Q376.13NDNDND
2010:Q485.08NDNDND
2011:Q194.13NDNDND
2011:Q2103.50103.50103.50103.50
Forecast
2011:Q399.5799.69101.4697.83
2011:Q4100.94101.20104.8197.44
2012:Q1101.75102.13107.6696.50
2012:Q2102.32102.83110.3295.35
2012:Q3102.61103.25112.7393.95
2012:Q4102.55103.33114.8192.25
Middle-right panel
Dollar
Dollars per barrel
Period June Tealbook Proposed forecast Additional 5 percent
dollar depreciation
Additional 5 percent
dollar appreciation
2010:Q178.69NDNDND
2010:Q277.89NDNDND
2010:Q376.13NDNDND
2010:Q485.08NDNDND
2011:Q194.13NDNDND
2011:Q2103.50103.50103.50103.50
Forecast
2011:Q399.5799.69100.9198.43
2011:Q4100.94101.20103.6898.65
2012:Q1101.75102.13105.9298.29
2012:Q2102.32102.83107.9597.72
2012:Q3102.61103.25109.7296.87
2012:Q4102.55103.33111.1395.71

Alternative Scenarios for Non-fuel Commodity Prices

Bottom-left panel
World GDP Growth
2010:Q1 = 100
Period June Tealbook Proposed forecast World growth ½
percentage point
faster
World growth ½
percentage point
slower
2010:Q1100.00NDNDND
2010:Q2103.94NDNDND
2010:Q3104.68NDNDND
2010:Q4118.82NDNDND
2011:Q1133.12NDNDND
2011:Q2134.04134.04134.04134.04
Forecast
2011:Q3133.74134.04135.84132.16
2011:Q4133.99134.60138.24130.86
2012:Q1134.31135.22140.74129.62
2012:Q2134.39135.61143.04128.18
2012:Q3134.22135.74145.10126.50
2012:Q4133.92135.74147.05124.73
Bottom-right panel
Dollar
2010:Q1 = 100
Period June Tealbook Proposed forecast Additional 5 percent
dollar depreciation
Additional 5 percent
dollar appreciation
2010:Q1100.00NDNDND
2010:Q2103.94NDNDND
2010:Q3104.68NDNDND
2010:Q4118.82NDNDND
2011:Q1133.12NDNDND
2011:Q2134.04134.04134.04134.04
Forecast
2011:Q3133.74134.04135.67132.35
2011:Q4133.99134.60137.89131.22
2012:Q1134.31135.22140.22130.16
2012:Q2134.39135.61142.32128.89
2012:Q3134.22135.74144.20127.38
2012:Q4133.92135.74145.95125.77

Exhibit 10
Financial Stability

Top-left panel
Financial Market Stress

Period Index
8 June 20010.19
15 June 20010.24
22 June 20010.15
29 June 20010.09
6 July 20010.07
13 July 20010.16
20 July 20010.17
27 July 20010.15
3 August 20010.10
10 August 20010.13
17 August 20010.25
24 August 20010.29
31 August 20010.26
7 September 20010.29
14 September 20010.64
21 September 20010.93
28 September 20010.83
5 October 20010.67
12 October 20010.58
19 October 20010.67
26 October 20010.66
2 November 20010.74
9 November 20010.59
16 November 20010.38
23 November 20010.32
30 November 20010.40
7 December 20010.36
14 December 20010.38
21 December 20010.43
28 December 20010.37
4 January 20020.36
11 January 20020.22
18 January 20020.22
25 January 20020.19
1 February 20020.13
8 February 20020.21
15 February 20020.16
22 February 20020.16
1 March 20020.12
8 March 20020.12
15 March 20020.11
22 March 20020.11
29 March 20020.14
5 April 20020.14
12 April 20020.14
19 April 20020.14
26 April 20020.18
3 May 20020.19
10 May 20020.20
17 May 20020.14
24 May 20020.10
31 May 20020.10
7 June 20020.12
14 June 20020.16
21 June 20020.20
28 June 20020.27
5 July 20020.26
12 July 20020.32
19 July 20020.48
26 July 20020.85
2 August 20020.77
9 August 20020.88
16 August 20020.87
23 August 20020.85
30 August 20020.74
6 September 20020.77
13 September 20020.73
20 September 20020.79
27 September 20020.90
4 October 20020.92
11 October 20020.89
18 October 20020.90
25 October 20020.86
1 November 20020.85
8 November 20020.72
15 November 20020.58
22 November 20020.46
29 November 20020.41
6 December 20020.39
13 December 20020.37
20 December 20020.35
27 December 20020.31
3 January 20030.38
10 January 20030.22
17 January 20030.21
24 January 20030.31
31 January 20030.42
7 February 20030.36
14 February 20030.43
21 February 20030.37
28 February 20030.31
7 March 20030.35
14 March 20030.50
21 March 20030.48
28 March 20030.37
4 April 20030.37
11 April 20030.23
18 April 20030.14
25 April 20030.15
2 May 20030.11
9 May 20030.05
16 May 20030.05
23 May 20030.08
30 May 20030.07
6 June 20030.09
13 June 20030.08
20 June 20030.09
27 June 20030.07
4 July 20030.06
11 July 20030.05
18 July 20030.06
25 July 20030.06
1 August 20030.15
8 August 20030.21
15 August 20030.20
22 August 20030.17
29 August 20030.15
5 September 20030.11
12 September 20030.11
19 September 20030.07
26 September 20030.08
3 October 20030.08
10 October 20030.06
17 October 20030.09
24 October 20030.11
31 October 20030.11
7 November 20030.09
14 November 20030.07
21 November 20030.08
28 November 20030.05
5 December 20030.07
12 December 20030.05
19 December 20030.04
26 December 20030.07
2 January 20040.06
9 January 20040.04
16 January 20040.03
23 January 20040.05
30 January 20040.05
6 February 20040.08
13 February 20040.06
20 February 20040.04
27 February 20040.04
5 March 20040.04
12 March 20040.05
19 March 20040.06
26 March 20040.06
2 April 20040.11
9 April 20040.14
16 April 20040.12
23 April 20040.13
30 April 20040.17
7 May 20040.18
14 May 20040.14
21 May 20040.16
28 May 20040.13
4 June 20040.09
11 June 20040.04
18 June 20040.03
25 June 20040.03
2 July 20040.03
9 July 20040.04
16 July 20040.03
23 July 20040.03
30 July 20040.03
6 August 20040.05
13 August 20040.06
20 August 20040.07
27 August 20040.06
3 September 20040.05
10 September 20040.02
17 September 20040.02
24 September 20040.02
1 October 20040.01
8 October 20040.01
15 October 20040.01
22 October 20040.01
29 October 20040.01
5 November 20040.01
12 November 20040.01
19 November 20040.01
26 November 20040.01
3 December 20040.01
10 December 20040.01
17 December 20040.01
24 December 20040.01
31 December 20040.01
7 January 20050.01
14 January 20050.00
21 January 20050.01
28 January 20050.00
4 February 20050.00
11 February 20050.00
18 February 20050.00
25 February 20050.00
4 March 20050.00
11 March 20050.00
18 March 20050.00
25 March 20050.00
1 April 20050.00
8 April 20050.01
15 April 20050.01
22 April 20050.01
29 April 20050.01
6 May 20050.01
13 May 20050.01
20 May 20050.01
27 May 20050.01
3 June 20050.01
10 June 20050.01
17 June 20050.01
24 June 20050.01
1 July 20050.01
8 July 20050.02
15 July 20050.01
22 July 20050.01
29 July 20050.01
5 August 20050.01
12 August 20050.01
19 August 20050.02
26 August 20050.02
2 September 20050.02
9 September 20050.02
16 September 20050.02
23 September 20050.02
30 September 20050.02
7 October 20050.03
14 October 20050.03
21 October 20050.02
28 October 20050.02
4 November 20050.01
11 November 20050.02
18 November 20050.02
25 November 20050.01
2 December 20050.01
9 December 20050.01
16 December 20050.01
23 December 20050.01
30 December 20050.01
6 January 20060.01
13 January 20060.00
20 January 20060.01
27 January 20060.01
3 February 20060.01
10 February 20060.01
17 February 20060.01
24 February 20060.01
3 March 20060.00
10 March 20060.01
17 March 20060.01
24 March 20060.00
31 March 20060.01
7 April 20060.01
14 April 20060.00
21 April 20060.01
28 April 20060.00
5 May 20060.00
12 May 20060.01
19 May 20060.01
26 May 20060.02
2 June 20060.02
9 June 20060.01
16 June 20060.01
23 June 20060.01
30 June 20060.01
7 July 20060.01
14 July 20060.01
21 July 20060.01
28 July 20060.01
4 August 20060.01
11 August 20060.01
18 August 20060.01
25 August 20060.00
1 September 20060.00
8 September 20060.00
15 September 20060.00
22 September 20060.00
29 September 20060.00
6 October 20060.00
13 October 20060.00
20 October 20060.00
27 October 20060.00
3 November 20060.00
10 November 20060.00
17 November 20060.00
24 November 20060.00
1 December 20060.00
8 December 20060.01
15 December 20060.01
22 December 20060.01
29 December 20060.01
5 January 20070.01
12 January 20070.01
19 January 20070.01
26 January 20070.00
2 February 20070.01
9 February 20070.01
16 February 20070.01
23 February 20070.01
2 March 20070.10
9 March 20070.15
16 March 20070.14
23 March 20070.10
30 March 20070.12
6 April 20070.09
13 April 20070.06
20 April 20070.06
27 April 20070.05
4 May 20070.05
11 May 20070.04
18 May 20070.04
25 May 20070.03
1 June 20070.03
8 June 20070.03
15 June 20070.04
22 June 20070.04
29 June 20070.07
6 July 20070.05
13 July 20070.05
20 July 20070.06
27 July 20070.25
3 August 20070.55
10 August 20070.64
17 August 20070.91
24 August 20070.82
31 August 20070.76
7 September 20070.78
14 September 20070.83
21 September 20070.60
28 September 20070.45
5 October 20070.29
12 October 20070.15
19 October 20070.25
26 October 20070.43
2 November 20070.37
9 November 20070.62
16 November 20070.75
23 November 20070.93
30 November 20070.92
7 December 20070.93
14 December 20070.91
21 December 20070.91
28 December 20070.86
4 January 20080.90
11 January 20080.85
18 January 20080.89
25 January 20080.94
1 February 20080.89
8 February 20080.93
15 February 20080.93
22 February 20080.95
29 February 20080.92
7 March 20080.98
14 March 20080.98
21 March 20080.96
28 March 20080.92
4 April 20080.78
11 April 20080.59
18 April 20080.60
25 April 20080.45
2 May 20080.25
9 May 20080.22
16 May 20080.28
23 May 20080.34
30 May 20080.51
6 June 20080.67
13 June 20080.79
20 June 20080.68
27 June 20080.75
4 July 20080.74
11 July 20080.83
18 July 20080.84
25 July 20080.73
1 August 20080.69
8 August 20080.56
15 August 20080.60
22 August 20080.70
29 August 20080.76
5 September 20080.58
12 September 20080.68
19 September 20081.00
26 September 20081.00
3 October 20081.00
10 October 20081.00
17 October 20081.00
24 October 20081.00
31 October 20081.00
7 November 20081.00
14 November 20081.00
21 November 20081.00
28 November 20081.00
5 December 20081.00
12 December 20081.00
19 December 20081.00
26 December 20081.00
2 January 20091.00
9 January 20091.00
16 January 20091.00
23 January 20091.00
30 January 20091.00
6 February 20091.00
13 February 20091.00
20 February 20091.00
27 February 20091.00
6 March 20091.00
13 March 20091.00
20 March 20091.00
27 March 20090.99
3 April 20090.99
10 April 20090.97
17 April 20090.92
24 April 20090.91
1 May 20090.90
8 May 20090.83
15 May 20090.81
22 May 20090.87
29 May 20090.92
5 June 20090.84
12 June 20090.85
19 June 20090.81
26 June 20090.77
3 July 20090.72
10 July 20090.87
17 July 20090.90
24 July 20090.78
31 July 20090.68
7 August 20090.77
14 August 20090.76
21 August 20090.78
28 August 20090.69
4 September 20090.68
11 September 20090.58
18 September 20090.59
25 September 20090.60
2 October 20090.59
9 October 20090.54
16 October 20090.59
23 October 20090.57
30 October 20090.62
6 November 20090.64
13 November 20090.46
20 November 20090.38
27 November 20090.40
4 December 20090.41
11 December 20090.32
18 December 20090.21
25 December 20090.24
1 January 20100.21
8 January 20100.23
15 January 20100.15
22 January 20100.18
29 January 20100.25
5 February 20100.22
12 February 20100.30
19 February 20100.20
26 February 20100.12
5 March 20100.08
12 March 20100.06
19 March 20100.04
26 March 20100.05
2 April 20100.04
9 April 20100.04
16 April 20100.02
23 April 20100.03
30 April 20100.05
7 May 20100.47
14 May 20100.51
21 May 20100.76
28 May 20100.83
4 June 20100.78
11 June 20100.84
18 June 20100.61
25 June 20100.48
2 July 20100.48
9 July 20100.42
16 July 20100.28
23 July 20100.23
30 July 20100.17
6 August 20100.19
13 August 20100.26
20 August 20100.41
27 August 20100.63
3 September 20100.68
10 September 20100.67
17 September 20100.60
24 September 20100.51
1 October 20100.51
8 October 20100.42
15 October 20100.39
22 October 20100.36
29 October 20100.30
5 November 20100.15
12 November 20100.18
19 November 20100.17
26 November 20100.17
3 December 20100.29
10 December 20100.23
17 December 20100.21
24 December 20100.11
31 December 20100.10
7 January 20110.11
14 January 20110.06
21 January 20110.05
28 January 20110.04
4 February 20110.04
11 February 20110.03
18 February 20110.03
25 February 20110.05
4 March 20110.05
11 March 20110.06
18 March 20110.14
25 March 20110.09
1 April 20110.07
8 April 20110.06
15 April 20110.07
22 April 20110.06
29 April 20110.06
6 May 20110.07
13 May 20110.07
20 May 20110.09
27 May 20110.10
3 June 20110.12
10 June 20110.18
17 June 20110.34

Note: Shaded bars indicate periods of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research: March 2001-November 2001, and December 2007-June 2009.

Source: Staff calculations.

Top-right panel
Nonfinancial Debt

Ratio to GDP
Period Federal government State and local governments Private Sum
2001:Q10.340.121.361.82
2001:Q20.320.121.371.81
2001:Q30.320.121.391.83
2001:Q40.330.131.411.87
2002:Q10.330.131.411.87
2002:Q20.330.131.421.88
2002:Q30.330.131.431.89
2002:Q40.340.131.451.92
2003:Q10.340.141.461.94
2003:Q20.350.141.471.96
2003:Q30.350.141.471.96
2003:Q40.350.141.481.97
2004:Q10.360.141.481.98
2004:Q20.360.141.491.99
2004:Q30.360.141.502.00
2004:Q40.360.141.512.01
2005:Q10.370.141.512.02
2005:Q20.360.141.532.03
2005:Q30.360.141.552.05
2005:Q40.360.141.572.07
2006:Q10.370.141.572.08
2006:Q20.360.141.602.10
2006:Q30.360.141.622.12
2006:Q40.360.151.642.15
2007:Q10.370.151.652.17
2007:Q20.350.151.662.16
2007:Q30.360.151.692.20
2007:Q40.360.151.712.22
2008:Q10.370.161.722.25
2008:Q20.360.151.722.23
2008:Q30.400.151.732.28
2008:Q40.450.161.762.37
2009:Q10.490.161.772.42
2009:Q20.510.161.772.44
2009:Q30.530.161.742.43
2009:Q40.550.171.712.43
2010:Q10.570.171.682.42
2010:Q20.590.161.662.41
2010:Q30.610.161.642.41
2010:Q40.630.171.632.43
2011:Q10.640.161.622.42

Middle-left panel
Commercial Bank Assets Funded by Non-deposit Short-term Debt

Period Percent of assets
2001:Q131.19
2001:Q231.04
2001:Q330.72
2001:Q428.63
2002:Q128.44
2002:Q228.46
2002:Q328.00
2002:Q427.95
2003:Q127.52
2003:Q227.80
2003:Q327.84
2003:Q427.82
2004:Q128.33
2004:Q229.11
2004:Q328.64
2004:Q427.98
2005:Q128.67
2005:Q228.83
2005:Q329.36
2005:Q429.48
2006:Q130.27
2006:Q231.47
2006:Q332.51
2006:Q431.81
2007:Q131.46
2007:Q232.39
2007:Q333.06
2007:Q433.19
2008:Q133.02
2008:Q233.30
2008:Q333.06
2008:Q431.42
2009:Q130.32
2009:Q229.51
2009:Q328.84
2009:Q427.02
2010:Q126.80
2010:Q225.89
2010:Q325.82
2010:Q424.90
2011:Q124.62

Note: Shaded bars indicate periods of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research: March 2001-November 2001, and December 2007-June 2009.

Source: Call Report

Middle-right panel
Nonfinancial Sector Liabilities Funded by Non-deposit Short-term Debt

Period Percent of total liabilities
2001:Q119.58
2001:Q219.37
2001:Q319.78
2001:Q418.95
2002:Q118.61
2002:Q218.45
2002:Q318.41
2002:Q418.47
2003:Q118.63
2003:Q218.60
2003:Q318.48
2003:Q418.16
2004:Q117.96
2004:Q217.89
2004:Q318.10
2004:Q417.67
2005:Q117.91
2005:Q217.72
2005:Q317.89
2005:Q418.02
2006:Q118.43
2006:Q218.87
2006:Q319.40
2006:Q419.29
2007:Q119.17
2007:Q219.28
2007:Q320.20
2007:Q420.52
2008:Q121.37
2008:Q221.31
2008:Q321.46
2008:Q421.51
2009:Q120.36
2009:Q219.63
2009:Q318.24
2009:Q417.00
2010:Q115.86
2010:Q215.19
2010:Q314.72
2010:Q414.21

Note: Shaded bars indicate periods of business recession as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research: March 2001-November 2001, and December 2007-June 2009.

Source: Staff calculations

Bottom-left panel
U.S. MMF European Exposures*

Percent of MMF assets
Period Spain Italy Ireland Other Europe
19 May 20103.342.140.3549.53
2 June 20102.721.670.3949.12
16 June 20102.571.480.4351.26
30 June 20102.671.740.4949.75
14 July 20102.581.530.5054.29
28 July 20102.451.510.5055.96
11 August 20102.852.200.4855.94
25 August 20102.732.120.4857.15
8 September 20102.802.300.2256.70
22 September 20102.812.060.2056.29
6 October 20102.902.130.0456.27
20 October 20102.951.900.0055.57
3 November 20102.901.820.0057.15
17 November 20102.251.720.0057.73
1 December 20101.801.520.0057.04
15 December 20101.151.220.0055.77
29 December 20101.151.250.0055.26
12 January 20111.161.190.0053.92
26 January 20111.111.550.0054.37
9 February 20111.101.370.0054.64
23 February 20110.841.020.0054.48
9 March 20110.911.060.0054.91
23 March 20110.891.050.0055.50
6 April 20110.951.030.0055.57
20 April 20111.050.940.0054.91
4 May 20111.041.120.0055.41
18 May 20110.841.020.0056.13
1 June 20110.750.930.0056.29

* Unsecured debt, ABCP, and repurchase agreements.  Return to text

Source: Investment Company Institute.

Bottom-right panel
Distribution of U.S. MMF Exposures to Spain

Percent of fund assets Number of funds
0 - 0.5188
0.5 - 3 *46
3 - 5 *23
5+ *5

* Exposures large enough such that defaults on Spanish paper could cause MMFs to "break the buck"  Return to table

Source: SEC form N-MFP filings.


Exhibit 11
LISCC Firm Market Indicators

Top-left panel
Stock Prices

End of week
April 26, 2011 = 100
Period Bank of America Citigroup Other*
7 May 2010131.9188.6998.17
14 May 2010133.2288.2598.04
21 May 2010130.3683.1494.93
28 May 2010128.3187.8093.48
4 June 2010125.2084.0390.00
11 June 2010127.2586.0390.03
18 June 2010129.0588.9190.71
25 June 2010125.7887.3689.04
2 July 2010112.8584.0382.31
9 July 2011123.2489.5889.11
16 July 2010113.9986.4789.24
23 July 2010112.0389.1392.81
30 July 2010114.4890.9192.88
6 August 2011113.8390.0294.28
13 August 2010107.9486.0389.02
20 August 2010104.9983.1487.98
27 August 2010103.1183.3785.58
3 September 2010110.2386.6991.05
10 September 2010110.6486.6991.56
17 September 2010109.4187.5891.49
24 September 2010111.0586.4790.33
1 October 2010108.5990.6990.01
8 October 2010107.6192.9091.54
15 October 201097.7987.5888.94
22 October 201093.3791.1390.84
29 October 201093.4592.4691.76
5 November 2010100.9099.56100.56
12 November 201098.9495.1296.48
19 November 201095.1794.6896.50
26 November 201090.7591.1393.58
3 December 201096.8998.6798.00
10 December 2010104.58105.77101.51
17 December 2010102.70104.2199.83
24 December 2010NDNDND
31 December 2010109.00104.88103.30
7 January 2011116.45109.54105.38
14 January 2011124.63113.75109.67
21 January 2011116.45108.43108.52
28 January 2011111.13104.66105.50
4 February 2011116.78106.88106.96
11 February 2011120.70108.21109.56
18 February 2011120.54108.87109.55
25 February 2011116.04104.21106.80
4 March 2011115.47100.67104.08
11 March 2011117.59101.33103.53
18 March 2011114.8199.78102.86
25 March 2011109.0898.89102.78
1 April 2011109.3398.67104.34
8 April 2011110.23101.11104.52
15 April 2011104.8398.00101.47
22 April 2011NDNDND
29 April 2011100.41101.77100.31
11 May 2011100.65100.2298.69
13 May 201197.5592.0895.49
20 May 201194.6890.9595.16
27 May 201195.5890.8694.85
3 June 201192.3188.3891.60
10 June 201188.3884.1090.22
17 June 201187.4084.9491.17

* Composed of Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, State Street, Wells Fargo, and BONY.  Return to table

Source: Bloomberg.

Top-right panel
5-year CDS Spreads

End of week
Percent
Period Bank of America Citigroup Other*
7 May 20101.752.161.69
14 May 20101.461.771.40
21 May 20101.621.971.64
28 May 20101.541.751.56
4 June 20101.611.911.63
11 June 20101.692.101.94
18 June 20101.411.701.56
25 June 20101.541.821.73
2 July 20101.621.871.74
9 July 20101.431.701.54
16 July 20101.501.781.51
23 July 20101.441.691.40
30 July 20101.481.641.38
6 August 20101.461.621.33
13 August 20101.531.741.43
20 August 20101.641.781.46
27 August 20101.881.901.44
3 September 20101.701.751.27
10 September 20101.631.711.21
17 September 20101.601.741.21
24 September 20101.681.751.21
1 October 20101.651.72ND
8 October 20101.591.57ND
15 October 20102.071.761.26
22 October 20102.051.591.23
29 October 20101.891.501.22
5 November 20101.771.391.11
12 November 20101.851.60ND
19 November 20101.831.521.17
26 November 20101.981.641.25
3 December 20101.941.581.18
10 December 20101.901.451.15
17 December 20101.771.401.14
24 December 20101.841.501.14
31 December 20101.821.491.16
7 January 20111.781.581.19
14 January 20111.671.481.13
21 January 20111.611.431.12
28 January 20111.661.431.11
4 February 20111.451.271.09
11 February 20111.391.28ND
18 February 20111.331.25ND
25 February 20111.421.36ND
4 March 20111.401.26ND
11 March 20111.451.33ND
18 March 20111.411.33ND
25 March 20111.351.25ND
1 April 20111.321.23ND
8 April 20111.311.211.01
15 April 20111.341.241.05
22 April 20111.351.241.05
29 April 20111.331.231.06
11 May 20111.311.241.07
13 May 20111.361.251.10
20 May 20111.391.261.11
27 May 20111.451.271.13
3 June 20111.521.361.18
10 June 20111.721.521.23
17 June 20111.721.511.22

* Composed of Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, State Street, Wells Fargo, and BONY.  Return to table

Source: Markit.

Middle-left panel
Heat Map of Market Indicator Levels

CDS
Spreads
CDS
Relative1
Spreads
EDFs Relative1
EDFs
Market
Equity
Ratio
Bank of Americayelloworangeredredyellow
Morgan Stanleyorangeyellowyellow
Goldman Sachsyellowyellowyellow
Citigroupyellow
JP Morgan
State Street
Wells Fargo
BONYyellowred

Note: Yellow denotes current values from the 75th to 90th percentiles of the measure's distribution over the past 5 years, while orange denotes values between the 90th and 95th percentiles, and red denotes greater than the 95th percentile.

1 "Relative" implies a comparison to A-rated financial firms.  Return to table

Source: For CDS Spreads and Market equity ratio, Bloomberg; for EDFs, Moody's.

Middle-right panel
Downside Risks to LISCC Firms

  • Downgrade of short-term ratings of Bank of America or Citigroup.
  • Housing market deteriorates further.
  • Risk from peripheral Europe through core European firms.

Bottom-left panel
Conditional Value at Risk (CoVaR)

  • CoVaR is an estimate of the downside risk to the financial sector, conditional on a stress event for a firm.

Bottom-right panel
CoVar

Period Billions of dollars
January 200723.84
February 200722.35
March 200738.32
April 200730.06
May 200731.43
June 200734.22
July 200741.52
August 200767.39
September 200756.89
October 200743.46
November 200768.52
December 200757.14
January 200868.20
February 200872.30
March 200877.95
April 200853.78
May 200845.97
June 200857.87
July 200866.34
August 200851.01
September 200879.38
October 2008200.74
November 2008190.61
December 2008159.19
January 2009132.44
February 2009143.71
March 2009142.49
April 2009113.63
May 200996.73
June 200984.95
July 200978.73
August 200970.52
September 200977.78
October 200978.86
November 200976.47
December 200959.31
January 201064.04
February 201072.77
March 201047.59
April 201045.68
May 2010105.83
June 201098.43
July 201080.35
August 201080.57
September 201068.49
October 201066.59
November 201061.35
December 201051.89
January 201153.91
February 201151.36
March 201166.08
April 201150.13
May 201155.24

Note: The line represents the sum of the CoVar ratings for Bank of America, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, JP Morgan, State Street, Wells Fargo, and BONY.


Exhibit 12 (Last)
Emerging Risks: Asset Valuations and New Products

Top-left panel
Forward Spreads on High-yield Corporate Bonds

Percent
Period Near-term* Far-term**
January 20018.244.97
February 20017.354.47
March 20017.584.54
April 20018.464.34
May 20017.723.87
June 20017.803.96
July 20017.993.97
August 20018.133.64
September 20019.243.37
October 200110.103.51
November 200110.003.02
December 20018.602.86
January 20028.283.03
February 20027.873.22
March 20027.182.73
April 20026.902.87
May 20027.093.13
June 20027.333.97
July 20027.894.06
August 20028.694.57
September 20028.454.81
October 20029.505.18
November 20028.324.66
December 20027.554.51
January 20037.473.68
February 20037.653.91
March 20037.503.77
April 20037.093.05
May 20037.202.98
June 20037.102.91
July 20036.262.33
August 20036.552.13
September 20036.241.99
October 20036.071.73
November 20035.861.76
December 20035.571.55
January 20045.441.28
February 20045.791.50
March 20046.041.73
April 20045.381.51
May 20045.431.84
June 20045.301.95
July 20045.322.01
August 20045.382.10
September 20045.292.04
October 20045.171.98
November 20044.621.80
December 20044.441.73
January 20054.431.91
February 20054.231.92
March 20054.011.81
April 20054.752.24
May 20055.163.01
June 20054.793.06
July 20054.372.87
August 20054.172.89
September 20054.552.94
October 20054.423.11
November 20054.213.29
December 20054.093.43
January 20063.993.41
February 20063.883.32
March 20063.903.04
April 20063.732.75
May 20063.852.66
June 20064.103.01
July 20064.303.21
August 20064.293.31
September 20064.293.37
October 20064.143.28
November 20064.003.36
December 20063.873.41
January 20073.493.31
February 20073.363.18
March 20073.723.25
April 20073.652.97
May 20073.442.84
June 20073.282.76
July 20074.203.16
August 20075.163.30
September 20075.313.09
October 20075.042.96
November 20075.943.39
December 20076.393.37
January 20087.423.83
February 20088.013.62
March 20088.423.87
April 20087.534.00
May 20087.004.02
June 20087.004.08
July 20087.454.32
August 20087.174.50
September 20087.175.17
October 200811.167.21
November 200814.969.48
December 200816.1011.68
January 200913.009.30
February 200912.608.76
March 200913.5610.67
April 200911.358.33
May 200910.177.38
June 20099.346.18
July 20099.135.69
August 20098.185.01
September 20098.114.56
October 20097.424.06
November 20097.613.66
December 20097.113.43
January 20106.982.51
February 20107.502.53
March 20107.082.45
April 20106.952.20
May 20107.882.77
June 20108.523.08
July 20108.442.91
August 20108.442.93
September 20108.222.76
October 20108.042.08
November 20107.771.75
December 20107.241.74
January 20116.891.49
February 20116.261.41
March 20116.521.50
April 20116.361.36
May 20116.711.42
17 June 20117.441.39

* Near-term forward spreads between years two and three.  Return to table

** Far-term forward spreads between years nine and ten.  Return to table

Top-right panel
Gross Issuance of Junk Bonds*

Monthly rate
Period Billions of dollars
20056.66
200610.52
20079.76
20082.58
200910.34
201017.51
2011:Q117.67
2011:Q2e23.73

* Includes public, 144a, euro, and MTN issues.  Return to text

e. Estimate based on data through June 16, 2011.  Return to table

Middle-left panel
Institutional Leveraged-loan Issuance

Billions of dollars, monthly rate
Period New money Refinancings Sum
200511.698.3920.08
200622.847.6730.51
200726.269.2335.49
20084.960.845.80
20092.032.674.70
20108.698.5317.22
2011:Q112.8114.3227.13
2011:Q2eNDND32.46

e. Estimate based on data through May 2011 (approximate).  Return to table

Middle-right panel
Other Valuation Pressures

  • Real house prices in Taiwan and Hong Kong continue to rise rapidly despite actions taken by authorities to restrain increases.
  • Some equity markets in Latin America have elevated PE ratios, and in emerging Asia may reflect overly optimistic earnings outlooks.
  • In domestic markets, valuations for small capitalization stocks elevated relative to larger firms. Farm land valuations also high.

Bottom-left panel
Use of Leverage by Most Favored Hedge Funds

Percent of respondents
At or below trough0.00
Near trough5.88
Moderately above trough11.76
Middle64.71
Moderately below peak17.65
Near peak0.00
At or above peak0.00

Sources: Senior Credit Officer Opinion Survey on Dealer Financing Terms.

Bottom-right panel
New Products

  • Respond to new liquidity regulations inducing banks to lengthen liabilities, and new MMF rules further restricting investments in longer-term securities.
  • Putable CDs allow banks to issue long-maturity securities, while investors have the option to shorten.
  • Extendible repurchase agreements allow banks to issue short-maturity securities, but have the option to lengthen maturies.



Appendix 5: Materials used by Mr. Carpenter

Material for Briefing on
FOMC Participants' Economic Projections

Seth Carpenter
June 21, 2011

Exhibit 1. Central tendencies and ranges of economic projections, 2011-13 and over the longer run

Actual values for years 2006 through 2010.

Change in real GDP
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual2.42.3-2.80.22.8----
Upper End of Range-----3.04.04.53.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----2.93.74.22.8
Lower End of Central Tendency-----2.73.33.52.5
Lower End of Range-----2.52.23.02.4
Unemployment rate
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual4.54.86.910.09.6----
Upper End of Range-----9.18.78.36.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----8.98.27.55.6
Lower End of Central Tendency-----8.67.87.05.2
Lower End of Range-----8.47.56.55.0
PCE inflation
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual1.93.51.71.51.1----
Upper End of Range-----3.52.82.52.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----2.52.02.02.0
Lower End of Central Tendency-----2.31.51.51.7
Lower End of Range-----2.11.21.31.5
Core PCE inflation
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Actual2.32.42.01.70.8---
Upper End of Range-----2.32.52.5
Upper End of Central Tendency-----1.82.02.0
Lower End of Central Tendency-----1.51.41.4
Lower End of Range-----1.51.21.3

Exhibit 2. Economic projections for 2011-2013 and over the longer run (percent)

Change in real GDP
2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Central Tendency2.7 to 2.93.3 to 3.73.5 to 4.22.5 to 2.8
April projections3.1 to 3.33.5 to 4.23.5 to 4.32.5 to 2.8
Range2.5 to 3.02.2 to 4.03.0 to 4.52.4 to 3.0
April projections2.9 to 3.72.9 to 4.43.0 to 5.02.4 to 3.0
Memo: Tealbook2.73.54.2
April Tealbook3.24.24.3
Unemployment rate
2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Central Tendency8.6 to 8.97.8 to 8.27.0 to 7.55.2 to 5.6
April projections8.4 to 8.77.6 to 7.96.8 to 7.25.2 to 5.6
Range8.4 to 9.17.5 to 8.76.5 to 8.35.0 to 6.0
April projections8.1 to 8.97.1 to 8.46.0 to 8.45.0 to 6.0
Memo: Tealbook8.98.17.1
April Tealbook8.77.77.0
PCE inflation
2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Central Tendency2.3 to 2.51.5 to 2.01.5 to 2.01.7 to 2.0
April projections2.1 to 2.81.2 to 2.01.4 to 2.01.7 to 2.0
Range2.1 to 3.51.2 to 2.81.3 to 2.51.5 to 2.0
April projections2.0 to 3.61.0 to 2.81.2 to 2.51.5 to 2.0
Memo: Tealbook2.31.51.52
April Tealbook2.21.21.52
Core PCE inflation
2011 2012 2013
Central Tendency1.5 to 1.81.4 to 2.01.4 to 2.0
April projections1.3 to 1.61.3 to 1.81.4 to 2.0
Range1.5 to 2.31.2 to 2.51.3 to 2.5
April projections1.1 to 2.01.1 to 2.01.2 to 2.0
Memo: Tealbook1.71.51.5
April Tealbook1.41.41.5

Note: The changes in real GDP and inflation are measured Q4/Q4


Exhibit 3. Risks and uncertainty in economic projections

Top-left panel
Uncertainty about GDP growth

Number of participants
Lower   Similar    Higher
June projections0413
April projections1511

Top-right panel
Risks to GDP growth

Number of participants
Downside Balanced Upside
June projections1160
April projections593

Bottom-left panel
Uncertainty about PCE inflation

Number of participants
Lower   Similar    Higher
June projections1214
April projections1313

Bottom-right panel
Risks to PCE inflation

Number of participants
Downside Balanced Upside
June projections1106
April projections179

Exhibit 4. Central tendencies and ranges of economic projections, 2011-13 and over the longer run

Actual values for years 2006 through 2010.

[Note: Appendix 5, Exhibit 4 shows fan-chart versions of the first three charts in Appendix 5, Exhibit 1.]

Change in real GDP
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual2.42.3-2.80.22.8----
Upper End of Range-----3.04.04.53.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----2.93.74.22.8
Lower End of Central Tendency-----2.73.33.52.5
Lower End of Range-----2.52.23.02.4
Unemployment rate
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual4.54.86.910.09.6----
Upper End of Range-----9.18.78.36.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----8.98.27.55.6
Lower End of Central Tendency-----8.67.87.05.2
Lower End of Range-----8.47.56.55.0
PCE inflation
Percent
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Longer run
Actual1.93.51.71.51.1----
Upper End of Range-----3.52.82.52.0
Upper End of Central Tendency-----2.52.02.02.0
Lower End of Central Tendency-----2.31.51.51.7
Lower End of Range-----2.11.21.31.5



Appendix 6: Materials used by Mr. English

Material for
FOMC Briefing on Monetary Policy Alternatives

Bill English
June 22, 2011

April FOMC Statement

  1. Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in March indicates that the economic recovery is proceeding at a moderate pace and overall conditions in the labor market are improving gradually. Household spending and business investment in equipment and software continue to expand. However, investment in nonresidential structures is still weak, and the housing sector continues to be depressed. Commodity prices have risen significantly since last summer, and concerns about global supplies of crude oil have contributed to a further increase in oil prices since the Committee met in March. Inflation has picked up in recent months, but longer-term inflation expectations have remained stable and measures of underlying inflation are still subdued.
  2. Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Committee seeks to foster maximum employment and price stability. The unemployment rate remains elevated, and measures of underlying inflation continue to be somewhat low, relative to levels that the Committee judges to be consistent, over the longer run, with its dual mandate. Increases in the prices of energy and other commodities have pushed up inflation in recent months. The Committee expects these effects to be transitory, but it will pay close attention to the evolution of inflation and inflation expectations. The Committee continues to anticipate a gradual return to higher levels of resource utilization in a context of price stability.
  3. To promote a stronger pace of economic recovery and to help ensure that inflation, over time, is at levels consistent with its mandate, the Committee decided today to continue expanding its holdings of securities as announced in November. In particular, the Committee is maintaining its existing policy of reinvesting principal payments from its securities holdings and will complete purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities by the end of the current quarter. The Committee will regularly review the size and composition of its securities holdings in light of incoming information and is prepared to adjust those holdings as needed to best foster maximum employment and price stability.
  4. The Committee will maintain the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to ¼ percent and continues to anticipate that economic conditions, including low rates of resource utilization, subdued inflation trends, and stable inflation expectations, are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate for an extended period.
  5. The Committee will continue to monitor the economic outlook and financial developments and will employ its policy tools as necessary to support the economic recovery and to help ensure that inflation, over time, is at levels consistent with its mandate.

[Note: In the June FOMC Statement Alternatives, emphasis (strike-through) indicates strike-through text in the original document, and strong emphasis (bold) indicates bold red underlined text in the original document.]

June FOMC Statement--Alternative A

  1. Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in April suggests that the economic recovery is continuing at a moderate pace, though more slowly than the Committee had expected. Moreover, a number of indicators suggest a loss of momentum in the labor market. The slower pace of the recovery reflects in part some factors that are likely to be temporary, including the damping effect of higher food and energy prices on consumer purchasing power and spending as well as supply chain disruptions associated with the tragic events in Japan. Household spending and business investment in equipment and software continue to expand. However, investment in nonresidential structures is still weak, and the housing sector continues to be depressed. Inflation has picked up in recent months, mainly reflecting higher prices for some commodities and imported goods, as well as the recent supply chain disruptions. Although firms are facing cost pressures from high commodity prices, the pass-through into the prices of non-energy consumer goods and services has been relatively limited, and longer-term inflation expectations have remained stable.
  2. Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Committee seeks to foster maximum employment and price stability. The unemployment rate remains elevated; however, the Committee expects the pace of recovery to pick up over coming quarters and the unemployment rate to resume its gradual decline toward levels that the Committee judges to be consistent with its dual mandate. The Committee perceives that the downside risks to the economic outlook have increased somewhat. Inflation has moved up recently, but the Committee anticipates that inflation will subside to levels at or below those consistent with the Committee's dual mandate as the effects on inflation of past energy and other commodity price increases dissipate.
  3. To promote the ongoing economic recovery and to help ensure that inflation, over time, is at levels consistent with its mandate, the Committee is keeping the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to ¼ percent and now anticipates that economic conditions--including low rates of resource utilization and a subdued outlook for inflation over the medium run--are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate at least through the end of 2012. The Committee likewise anticipates that economic conditions will warrant the maintenance of its existing policy of reinvesting principal payments from its securities holdings at least through mid-2012. The Committee will complete its purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities by the end of this month. The Committee will regularly review the size and composition of its securities holdings and is prepared to expand those holdings if needed.
  4. The Committee will monitor the economic outlook and financial developments and will act as needed to best foster maximum employment and price stability.

June FOMC Statement--Alternative B

  1. Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in April indicates that the economic recovery is continuing at a moderate pace, though somewhat more slowly than the Committee had expected. Some indicators also suggest a loss of momentum in the labor market. The slower pace of the recovery reflects in part some factors that are likely to be temporary, including the damping effect of higher food and energy prices on consumer purchasing power and spending as well as supply chain disruptions associated with the tragic events in Japan. Household spending and business investment in equipment and software continue to expand. However, investment in nonresidential structures is still weak, and the housing sector continues to be depressed. Inflation has picked up in recent months, mainly reflecting higher prices for some commodities and imported goods, as well as the recent supply chain disruptions. However, longer-term inflation expectations have remained stable.
  2. Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Committee seeks to foster maximum employment and price stability. The unemployment rate remains elevated; however, the Committee expects the pace of recovery to pick up over coming quarters and the unemployment rate to resume its gradual decline toward levels that the Committee judges to be consistent with its dual mandate. Inflation has moved up recently, but the Committee anticipates that inflation will subside to levels at or below those consistent with the Committee's dual mandate as the effects on inflation of past energy and other commodity price increases dissipate. However, the Committee will continue to pay close attention to the evolution of inflation and inflation expectations.
  3. To promote the ongoing economic recovery and to help ensure that inflation, over time, is at levels consistent with its mandate, the Committee decided today to maintain the current degree of monetary policy accommodation. In particular, the Committee will keep the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to ¼ percent and continues to anticipate that economic conditions--including low rates of resource utilization and a subdued outlook for inflation over the medium run--are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate for an extended period. The Committee will complete its purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities by the end of this month and will maintain its existing policy of reinvesting principal payments from its securities holdings. The Committee will regularly review the size and composition of its securities holdings and is prepared to adjust those holdings as appropriate.
  4. The Committee will monitor the economic outlook and financial developments and will act as needed to best foster maximum employment and price stability.

June FOMC Statement--Alternative C

  1. Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in April indicates that the economic recovery is continuing at a moderate pace, though somewhat more slowly than the Committee had expected. Some indicators also suggest a loss of momentum in the labor market. The slower pace of the recovery reflects in part some factors that are likely to be temporary, including the damping effect of higher food and energy prices on consumer purchasing power and spending as well as supply chain disruptions associated with the tragic events in Japan. Household spending and business investment in equipment and software continue to expand. However, investment in nonresidential structures is still weak, and the housing sector continues to be depressed. Inflation has picked up in recent months, as firms are facing cost pressures from increased commodity prices and import prices have risen. Longer-term inflation expectations have remained stable.
  2. Consistent with its statutory mandate, the Committee seeks to foster maximum employment and price stability. The unemployment rate remains elevated; however, the Committee expects the pace of recovery to pick up over coming quarters and the unemployment rate to resume its gradual decline toward levels that the Committee judges to be consistent with its dual mandate. Inflation has moved up recently, but the Committee anticipates that inflation will subside to levels at or below those consistent with the Committee's dual mandate as the effects on inflation of past energy and other commodity price increases dissipate. However, the upside risks to inflation have increased somewhat, and the Committee will continue to pay close attention to the evolution of inflation and inflation expectations.
  3. In order to help ensure that economic activity and inflation, over time, are at levels consistent with its mandate, the Committee decided today to keep the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to ¼ percent and anticipates that economic conditions--including low rates of resource utilization and a subdued outlook for inflation over the medium run--are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate for some time. The Committee will complete its purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities by the end of this month. In July, the Committee will begin a gradual reduction in the current extraordinary degree of policy accommodation by discontinuing its policy of reinvesting principal payments from its holdings of agency securities and Treasury securities. The Committee will regularly review the size and composition of its securities holdings and is prepared to adjust those holdings as appropriate.
  4. The Committee will monitor the economic outlook and financial developments and will act as needed to best foster maximum employment and price stability.

April 2011 FOMC Directive

The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run objectives, the Committee seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent with federal funds trading in a range from 0 to ¼ percent. The Committee directs the Desk to execute purchases of longer-term Treasury securities in order to increase the total face value of domestic securities held in the System Open Market Account to approximately $2.6 trillion by the end of June 2011. The Committee also directs the Desk to reinvest principal payments from agency debt and agency mortgage-backed securities in longer-term Treasury securities. The System Open Market Account Manager and the Secretary will keep the Committee informed of ongoing developments regarding the System's balance sheet that could affect the attainment over time of the Committee's objectives of maximum employment and price stability.

[Note: In the June 2011 FOMC Directive Alternatives, emphasis (strike-through) indicates strike-through text in the original document, and strong emphasis (bold) indicates bold red underlined text in the original document.]

June 2011 FOMC Directive -- Alternative A

The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run objectives, the Committee seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent with federal funds trading in a range from 0 to ¼ percent. The Committee directs the Desk to execute complete purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities in order to increase the total face value of domestic securities held in the System Open Market Account to approximately $2.6 trillion by the end of June 2011 this month. The Committee also directs the Desk to maintain its existing policy of reinvesting principal payments from agency debt and agency mortgage backed on all domestic securities in the System Open Market Account in longer term Treasury securities in order to maintain the total face value of domestic securities at approximately $2.6 trillion. The System Open Market Account Manager and the Secretary will keep the Committee informed of ongoing developments regarding the System's balance sheet that could affect the attainment over time of the Committee's objectives of maximum employment and price stability.

June 2011 FOMC Directive -- Alternative B

The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run objectives, the Committee seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent with federal funds trading in a range from 0 to ¼ percent. The Committee directs the Desk to execute complete purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities in order to increase the total face value of domestic securities held in the System Open Market Account to approximately $2.6 trillion by the end of June 2011 this month. The Committee also directs the Desk to maintain its existing policy of reinvesting principal payments from agency debt and agency mortgage backed on all domestic securities in the System Open Market Account in longer term Treasury securities in order to maintain the total face value of domestic securities at approximately $2.6 trillion. The System Open Market Account Manager and the Secretary will keep the Committee informed of ongoing developments regarding the System's balance sheet that could affect the attainment over time of the Committee's objectives of maximum employment and price stability.

June 2011 FOMC Directive -- Alternative C

The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run objectives, the Committee seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent with federal funds trading in a range from 0 to ¼ percent. The Committee directs the Desk to execute complete purchases of $600 billion of longer-term Treasury securities in order to increase the total face value of domestic securities held in the System Open Market Account to approximately $2.6 trillion by the end of June 2011 this month. The Committee also directs the Desk to cease all reinvestment of principal payments from agency debt and agency mortgage backed securities in longer term Treasury on domestic securities in the System Open Market Account from the beginning of July 2011. The System Open Market Account Manager and the Secretary will keep the Committee informed of ongoing developments regarding the System's balance sheet that could affect the attainment over time of the Committee's objectives of maximum employment and price stability.




Appendix 7: Materials used by Ms. Yellen

FOMC Policy on External Communications of Federal Reserve System Staff1

Preamble

In the course of making monetary policy decisions, the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) makes extensive use of background materials prepared by the staff of the Federal Reserve System, and senior staff give regular briefings at FOMC meetings. In addition, staff are directly involved in the implementation and communication of the Committee's policy decisions.

Federal Reserve System staff have contacts with members of the public in the process of gathering information about current economic and financial conditions. In addition, staff synthesize that information using a variety of analytical methods and statistical tools, and the continual refinement of these methods and tools is facilitated by ongoing interactions with academic researchers, staff at foreign central banks, and other outside analysts. Finally, staff play a significant role in helping the public understand the rationale for FOMC decisions.

To reinforce the public's confidence in the transparency and integrity of the monetary policy process, the FOMC has established the following principles to govern the public contacts of Federal Reserve System staff who have access to confidential FOMC information.2 The FOMC maintains responsibility for ensuring that all System staff abide by these principles. Specifically, the President of each Federal Reserve Bank is responsible for ensuring the confidentiality of FOMC information at that Bank and for the conduct and discretion of that Bank's staff with regard to the use of that information, and the Chairman fulfills this role for Board staff.

General Principles

  1. Federal Reserve staff play a significant role in enhancing public understanding of the FOMC's actions, thereby promoting the effectiveness of monetary policy. In all communications with the public regarding monetary policy issues, members of the official staff should refrain from publicly expressing their own personal views regarding prospective monetary policy decisions and should never speculate about future monetary policy decisions or actions that have not been announced by the Committee. In explaining the rationale for announced FOMC decisions, staff should draw on Committee communications, the Chairman's press conference remarks, and other published materials as appropriate. Whenever staff make public comments on monetary policy, they should clearly indicate that those comments are solely their own responsibility and should not be interpreted as representing the views of the FOMC, its principals, or any other person associated with the Federal Reserve System.
  2. To foster the ongoing frank exchange of views at FOMC meetings, staff will refrain from characterizing such discussions--apart from what has been published in the minutes of each FOMC meeting--in any contact with an individual, firm, or organization outside of the Federal Reserve System.
  3. To protect the independence of the FOMC's decision-making process from short-term political pressures, members of the official staff will strive to avoid any appearance of political partisanship in their contacts with the public.
  4. Staff will carefully safeguard all confidential FOMC information.3 No confidential information may be released except pursuant to Committee instructions or with written authorization from the Chairman and prompt notification to the Committee.
  5. To ensure that no member of the public is able to profit financially from acquiring nonpublic information about economic and financial conditions or about the methods and tools that are currently being used to assess those conditions, staff will not provide such information to any individual, firm, or organization outside of the Federal Reserve System unless the information has been cleared for publication and is made widely available to the public.
  6. Staff will strive to ensure that their contacts with members of the public do not provide any profit-making person or organization with a prestige advantage over its competitors. They will consider this principle carefully and rigorously in considering invitations to speak at meetings sponsored by profit-making organizations and in scheduling meetings with anyone who might benefit financially from apparently-exclusive contacts with Federal Reserve staff.
  7. To facilitate the effectiveness of the Committee's policy deliberations and the clarity of its communications, staff observe the blackout period on monetary policy communication that begins on the Tuesday morning of the week prior to each regularly-scheduled FOMC meeting and ends at midnight Eastern Time on the Thursday following the meeting. During each blackout period, staff refrain from providing information to members of the public about macroeconomic or financial developments or about current or prospective monetary policy issues unless that information has already been cleared for publication and made widely available to the public prior to the blackout period.

Practical Examples

To assist Federal Reserve System staff in understanding the application of these principles, the FOMC has considered how the principles should be applied to some common requests for public contact. For example, the following contacts would generally be consistent with the Committee's policy on external communications, as long as the staff member carefully adheres to all of the principles listed above during the contact itself:

  1. A presentation at a widely-attended meeting, where the event is organized by a non-profit entity and does not involve fundraising. Such a meeting might be sponsored by an academic institution, non-profit organization, or civic or trade association (such as a chamber of commerce or a state or national bankers' association).
  2. A private meeting with members of the public--such as bankers, community representatives, industry representatives, or labor representatives--to collect information about current economic and financial conditions, without disseminating any information that is not widely available to the public. Whenever practical, at least two Federal Reserve staff should be present at such a meeting.

In contrast, the following contacts would not be consistent with the principles set out above:

  1. Disclosure of confidential FOMC information.
  2. Disclosure or characterization of the views expressed at an FOMC meeting.
  3. Disclosure of an FOMC participant's personal views on monetary policy that have not previously been communicated to the public.
  4. Public communications in which a Federal Reserve officer expresses personal opinions about prospective monetary policy decisions.
  5. A prediction to members of the public about Committee action prior to the Committee's announcement of such decisions.
  6. A private meeting with selected clients of a regulated entity or financial firm to discuss monetary policy.

Of course, the foregoing examples are not intended to serve as an exhaustive list, and hence good judgment will be essential in applying these principles. Moreover, whenever staff are unsure about whether specific contacts with the public would be appropriate, they should consult in advance with the appropriate staff person or with the head of their respective institution--namely, the Chairman in the case of staff at the Board of Governors, and the President in the case of staff at a Federal Reserve Bank.

1 This document complements the FOMC policy regarding the external communications of Committee participants, which is set forth in a separate document.  Return to text

2 This policy is fully consistent with and complements the rules for ethical conduct prescribed for the staff of the Board of Governors and for staff at each Federal Reserve Bank.  Return to text

3 The Committee's regulations concerning the designation and handling of confidential FOMC information are set forth in a separate document, "Program for Security of FOMC Information."  Return to text


FOMC Policy on External Communications of Committee Participants1

Preamble

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) is committed to providing clear and timely information to the public about the Committee's monetary policy actions and the rationale for those decisions. Indeed, considerable evidence indicates that central bank transparency increases the effectiveness of monetary policy and enables households and businesses to make better-informed decisions.

Two-way communication with the public is a crucial element in the FOMC's monetary policy process. Committee participants have regular contacts with members of the public as part of the process of gathering the information the Committee needs to understand current economic and financial conditions. In addition, the FOMC's public accountability is strengthened by open discussion of Committee participants' views about the economic outlook as well as their judgments about the appropriate course of monetary policy.

Therefore, to reinforce the public's confidence in the transparency and integrity of the monetary policy process, the FOMC has established the following principles to govern Committee participants' contacts with members of the public. The FOMC itself maintains responsibility for ensuring that all Committee participants--that is, the members of the Federal Reserve Board and the presidents of the Federal Reserve Banks--abide by these principles.2

General Principles

  1. Committee participants will endeavor to enhance the public's understanding of monetary policy. They are free to explain their individual views but are expected to do so in a spirit of collegiality and to refrain from characterizing the views of other individuals on the Committee. In explaining the rationale for announced FOMC decisions, participants will draw on Committee communications and the Chairman's press conference remarks as appropriate.
  2. To foster the ongoing frank exchange of views at FOMC meetings, Committee participants will refrain from publicly characterizing such discussions beyond what has been published in the minutes of each FOMC meeting.
  3. To protect the independence of the FOMC's decision-making process from short-term political pressures, participants will strive to avoid any appearance of political partisanship and will be prudent in selecting venues for their speaking engagements.
  4. FOMC participants will carefully safeguard all confidential information.3 No confidential FOMC information may be released except pursuant to Committee instructions or with written authorization from the Chairman and prompt notification to the FOMC.
  5. To the fullest extent possible, Committee participants will refrain from describing their personal views about monetary policy in any meeting or conversation with any individual, firm, or organization who could profit financially from acquiring that information unless those views have already been expressed in their public communications.
  6. Committee participants will strive to ensure that their contacts with members of the public do not provide any profit-making person or organization with a prestige advantage over its competitors. They will consider this principle carefully and rigorously in scheduling meetings with anyone who might benefit financially from apparently exclusive contacts with Federal Reserve officials and in considering invitations to speak at meetings that are sponsored by profit-making organizations or that are closed to the public and the media.
  7. To facilitate the effectiveness of the Committee's policy deliberations and the clarity of its communications, participants observe a blackout period on monetary policy communication that begins on the Tuesday morning of the week prior to each regularly-scheduled FOMC meeting and ends at midnight Eastern Time on the Thursday following the meeting. During each blackout period, participants refrain from expressing their views about macroeconomic developments or monetary policy issues in meetings or conversations with members of the public.

Practical Examples

To assist FOMC participants in understanding the application of these principles, the Committee has considered how the principles should be applied to some common requests for public contact. For example, the following contacts would generally be consistent with the Committee's policy on external communications, as long as the participant carefully adheres to all of the principles listed above during the contact itself:

  1. A speech on a monetary policy topic at a widely-attended event with press in attendance, where the event is organized by a non-profit entity and does not involve fundraising. Such a speech might be given at an academic institution, a conference sponsored by a non-profit organization, or a meeting sponsored by a civic or trade association (such as a chamber of commerce or a state or national bankers' association).
  2. An interview with the press regarding the participant's personal views on monetary policy issues.
  3. A private meeting with members of the public--such as bankers, community representatives, industry representatives, or labor representatives--to collect information about the economy without disseminating any information about the participant's personal views on monetary policy unless those views have already been expressed in their public communications. Whenever practical, a public information officer or other Federal Reserve staff should be present at such a meeting.

In contrast, the following contacts would not be consistent with the principles set out above:

  1. Disclosure in any setting of confidential FOMC information.
  2. Disclosure or characterization in any setting of the views that others expressed at an FOMC meeting.
  3. A prediction about Committee action in advance of the Committee announcement of its decision.
  4. A private meeting with selected clients of a regulated entity or financial firm to discuss monetary policy.

Of course, the foregoing examples are not intended to serve as an exhaustive list, and hence good judgment will be essential in applying these principles.

1 The Committee's policy governing the external communications of Federal Reserve System staff is set forth in a separate document.  Return to text

2 This policy is fully consistent with and complements the more general policies for ethical conduct published in the Federal Reserve Administrative Manual (FRAM) section 2-026.1 ("Ethics--Voluntary Guide to Conduct for Senior Officials"). That section recognizes the overarching principle that senior Federal Reserve officials "have a special responsibility for maintaining the integrity, dignity, and reputation of the System" and "should scrupulously avoid conduct that might in any way tend to embarrass the System or impair the effectiveness of its operations." The policy in this document focuses specifically on external communications and is binding on all FOMC participants.  Return to text

3 The Committee's regulations concerning the designation and handling of confidential FOMC information are set forth in a separate document, "Program for Security of FOMC Information."  Return to text




Appendix 8: Materials used by Chairman Bernanke

Exit Strategy Principles

In light of discussions at the April and June FOMC meetings, the Committee has reached broad agreement on the key elements of the strategy that it expects to follow in normalizing the stance and conduct of monetary policy:

  1. The Committee will determine the timing and pace of policy normalization to promote its statutory mandate of maximum employment and price stability.
  2. To begin the process of policy normalization, the Committee will likely first cease reinvesting some or all payments of principal on the securities holdings in the System Open Market Account (SOMA).
  3. At the same time or sometime relatively soon thereafter, the Committee will modify its forward guidance on the path of the federal funds rate and will initiate temporary reserve-draining operations aimed at supporting the implementation of increases in the federal funds rate when appropriate.
  4. When economic conditions warrant, the Committee's next step in the process of policy normalization will be to begin raising its target for the federal funds rate, and from that point on, changing the level or range of the federal funds rate target will be the primary means of adjusting the stance of monetary policy. During the normalization process, adjustments to the interest rate on excess reserves and to the level of reserves in the banking system will be used to bring the funds rate toward its target.
  5. Sales of agency securities from the SOMA will likely commence sometime after the first increase in the target for the federal funds rate, probably within a few months. The timing and pace of sales will be communicated to the public in advance; that pace is anticipated to be relatively gradual and steady, but it could be adjusted up or down in response to material changes in the economic outlook or financial conditions.
  6. The pace of sales is expected to be aimed at eliminating our holdings of agency securities over a period of [ three | four ] to five years, thereby minimizing the extent to which the SOMA portfolio might affect the allocation of credit across sectors of the economy. Sales at this pace would be expected to normalize the size of the SOMA securities portfolio over a period of [ two to three | about three ] years. In particular, the size of the securities portfolio and the associated quantity of bank reserves are expected to be reduced to the smallest levels that would be consistent with the efficient implementation of monetary policy through the use of conventional open market operations to keep the federal funds rate near its target.
  7. The Committee is prepared to make adjustments to its exit strategy if necessary in light of economic and financial developments.

Return to topReturn to top



Home | Monetary policy | FOMC | FOMC transcripts
Accessibility | Contact Us
Last update: January 12, 2017