Greater Wealth, Greater Uncertainty: Changes in Racial Inequality in the Survey of Consumer Finances, Accessible Data

Figure 1. White and Asian Families Had the Most Wealth

(Top Panel) Median Wealth
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

  Median + Standard Error - Standard Error
White 285.01 297.19 272.81
Black 44.89 56.09 33.71
Hispanic 61.62 71.76 51.44
Other: Asian 536.02 632.98 439.02
Other: Mixed Race, Native American, and all remaining 62.9 70.87 54.93

(Bottom Panel) Mean Wealth
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

  Mean + Standard Error - Standard Error
White 1367.17 1401.64 1332.76
Black 211.45 238.25 184.75
Hispanic 227.49 249.08 205.92
Other: Asian 1826.86 2103.18 1550.62
Other: Mixed Race, Native American, and all remaining 389.44 428.55 350.25

Notes: Figure displays median (top panel) and mean (bottom panel) wealth by race and ethnicity, expressed in thousands of 2022 dollars. Due to an oversample of Asian families, the 2022 SCF can separate Asian families from non-Asian families for the first time (Moore and Pence, 2021). Standard errors use Pence (2015), with 999 bootstrap replicates.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 2. Wealth Gaps Persisted and Widened Slightly in 2022, Despite Faster Growth in Wealth for Black and Hispanic Families

(Top Panel) Median Wealth by Race
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

Year White Black Hispanic Other
1989 164.03 9.20 12.05 80.77
1992 144.42 20.51 14.02 76.97
1995 148.33 21.13 23.54 60.40
1998 174.75 28.26 17.91 69.97
2001 205.53 32.45 19.13 88.10
2004 221.47 32.09 23.98 111.44
2007 245.11 30.14 30.12 86.82
2010 178.28 21.80 22.13 58.18
2013 180.68 16.78 17.50 52.47
2016 210.94 21.09 25.42 79.80
2019 218.14 27.97 41.91 86.39
2022 285.01 44.89 61.62 132.90

(Bottom Panel) Mean Wealth by Race
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

Year White Black Hispanic Other
1989 524.41 95.53 104.43 354.56
1992 460.84 99.75 112.06 410.01
1995 485.85 85.39 118.97 400.72
1998 615.93 116.81 158.83 399.44
2001 818.30 119.89 148.10 518.06
2004 885.23 176.51 195.37 456.01
2007 993.14 192.41 266.37 564.78
2010 893.94 135.67 157.89 458.11
2013 898.46 126.01 137.06 473.59
2016 1,151.60 170.26 235.78 564.50
2019 1,140.01 165.14 191.85 761.81
2022 1,367.17 211.45 227.49 849.82

Note: Figures display median (left panel) and mean (right panel) wealth by race and ethnicity, expressed in thousands of 2022 dollars, over the history of the SCF.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 3. The Ratios of Wealth Between White and non-White Families Remained Unequal

Percent of Median White Wealth

Year Black Hispanic Other
2007 12.3 12.29 35.42
2010 12.23 12.41 32.64
2013 9.28 9.69 29.04
2016 10 12.05 37.83
2019 12.82 19.21 39.6
2022 15.75 21.62 46.63

Note: Figure displays wealth that the typical Black, Hispanic, and other race family had as a percent of the wealth of the typical White family.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 4. Increases in Net Housing Wealth Drove Wealth Growth, Especially for Black and Hispanic Families

Percent

  Overall Growth Other Wealth Net Housing Wealth Business Equity Stock (Corporate Equity) Liquid Assets
White 19.93 2.99 4.95 4.31 5.87 1.8
Black 28.05 3.07 19.13 5.87 1.12 -1.14
Hispanic 18.58 5.53 11.31 0.78 -0.07 1.03
Other 11.55 0.17 3.63 2.46 5.98 -0.69

Notes: Figure displays the contributions to growth in average wealth between 2019 and 2022 from various types of assets by race and ethnicity. Bars above zero indicate holdings of the asset increased, while bars below zero show holdings of the asset declined. Average total wealth growth for each race and ethnicity is denoted by the dots. Except for Hispanic families, contribution bars appear in the order in which they appear in the legend, though the other wealth contribution for other race families is small. The stock wealth contribution for Hispanic families is a small negative and appears below zero.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 5. Ownership Rates for Homes, Stock, and Businesses Increased for non-White Families Between 2019 and 2022

(Left Panel) Home Ownership
Percent

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 75.57 49.25 50.09 57.18
2010 75.33 48.5 49.06 54.89
2013 73.85 45.88 44.44 52.15
2016 72.51 44.71 45.52 53.62
2019 73.68 45 47.57 54.17
2022 73.15 46.34 51.09 57.34

(Center Panel) Stock Ownership
Percent

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 60.03 33.52 27.02 49.82
2010 58.24 30.15 24.98 43.13
2013 57.39 31.8 21.12 40.65
2016 61.01 31.44 28.1 47.14
2019 60.83 33.53 24.15 53.84
2022 65.61 39.21 28.3 56.77

(Right Panel) Business Ownership
Percent

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 15.78 6.07 6.13 12.96
2010 15.63 5.62 5.98 14.18
2013 13.88 6.14 5.38 10.35
2016 15.5 6.61 5.75 13.36
2019 16.49 4.81 7.04 11.95
2022 15.97 11 9.75 14.07

Notes: Figure displays the ownership rate for primary residences (left panel), stock (center panel), and businesses (right panel) by race and ethnicity.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 6. Net Home Value for the Typical Family that Owned Their Home Increased

(Left Panel) Net Housing Wealth
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 164.57 85.86 114.48 141.05
2010 120.19 68.29 60.09 81.95
2013 114.55 54.85 63.64 90.37
2016 138.75 69.07 86.34 133.57
2019 150.7 76.56 110.12 172.39
2022 205.37 123.00 135.00 217.19

(Center Panel) Stocks Value
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 57.24 21.47 16.31 28.62
2010 48.74 12.04 7.35 29.96
2013 62.05 10.72 10.18 33.60
2016 63.66 14.80 13.56 33.52
2019 58.66 16.73 17.28 33.36
2022 67.97 17.18 25.00 34.23

(Right Panel) Business Value
2022 Dollars (Thousands)

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 143.1 35.78 98.14 118.77
2010 132.73 40.97 34.45 68.66
2013 114.55 17.43 38.18 63.64
2016 123.34 33.60 37.00 83.25
2019 115.92 81.14 60.68 106.88
2022 105 41.70 40.00 50.00

Notes: Figure displays the value for the typical family of the primary residence net of all housing-secured debt (left panel), stocks (center panel), and businesses (right panel) among families that owned the respective assets, by race and ethnicity.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 7. Wages and Salaries Drove Income Growth for White and Other Families, while Non-Retirement Government Programs Supported Growth for Black and Hispanic Families

Percent

  Overall Growth Retirement and SSI Govt Transfers (non-retirement) Investments Business/Self-Employment Wages and Salaries Other Sources
White 16.05 1.1 0.39 8.45 0.48 6.16 -0.51
Black 6.9 -1.25 1.14 3.79 3.08 -0.03 0.17
Hispanic 5.45 1.62 1.44 0.65 1.21 1.05 -0.53
Other 4.09 -2.51 0.73 -1.14 0.45 7.43 -0.87

Notes: Figure displays the contributions to growth in average income between 2019 and 2022 from various income sources by race and ethnicity. Bars above zero indicate the income source grew, while bars below zero show the income source shrank. Average total income growth for each race and ethnicity is denoted by the dots. SSI is Supplemental Security Income. The figure excludes one Black family from the 2019 survey with the highest Retirement and SSI.* Contributions bars appear in the order listed in the legend except for the following: Retirement income appears below zero and other sources appears at the top for Black families. Investment income, retirement income, and other sources appear in this order descending from zero for other race families.

*This sentence was added on October 23, 2023. Return to text

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 8. Required Payment Burdens Fell for the Typical Family Across Race and Ethnicity in 2022

Percent of Income

Year White Black Hispanic Other
2007 20.57 29.39 31.66 26.42
2010 21.26 26.01 30.79 26.37
2013 19.55 29.22 32.86 25.66
2016 18.88 29.85 31.51 26.31
2019 19.01 28.73 31.53 26.14
2022 17.35 27.56 30.41 22.2

Notes: Figure displays the median share of pre-tax income families used to make required payments on loans, rent, and other fees by race and ethnicity, using the ''rent-inclusive payment-to-income ratio'' from Chang, Hsu, Pack, and Palumbo (2018). We look at families with positive income. Higher numbers indicate more income went to these required payments, and so higher numbers imply families had less income to otherwise spend or save.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 9. Especially Non-White Families Said Their Income Is Unusually Low

(Top Panel) Percent of Families with Income Lower than Normal
Percent

  2019 2022
White 11.85 13.95
Black 15.63 24.66
Hispanic 17.51 24.78
Other 16.72 23.02

(Bottom Panel) Percent of Families with Income Higher than Normal
Percent

  2019 2022
White 10.32 12.29
Black 7.92 7.13
Hispanic 5.89 8.79
Other 11.69 10.48

Notes: Figure displays the percent of families that said their income was lower (top panel) or higher (bottom panel) than a ''normal'' year, by race and ethnicity. The key identifies series in order from left to right.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 10. Larger Shares of Non-White Families Were Uncertain About Next Year's Income

Percent

  2019 2022
White 23.65 30.69
Black 45.41 59.58
Hispanic 47.69 58.6
Other 29.07 38.24

Notes: Figure displays the share of families that said they did not have a good idea of family income next year, by race and ethnicity. Non-White families were more likely than White families to be uncertain about future income. While families of all races and ethnicities were more uncertain about future income in 2022 than in 2019, the increase in uncertainty was larger for non-White families. The key identifies series in order from left to right.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Figure 11. More Families of All Races and Ethnicities Expected a Worse Economy over the Next Five Years

Percent

  2019 2022
White 25.38 46.42
Black 22.29 32.78
Hispanic 22.34 42.79
Other 27.83 42.02

Notes: Figure displays the percent of families that said they expected the economy to perform worse over the next five years, compared to the previous five years, by race and ethnicity. A much higher share of families of each race and ethnicity displayed pessimism about the future economy in 2022 than in 2019. The key identifies series in order from left to right.

Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2023).

Return to text

Last Update: October 23, 2023